I've been using both vars successfully so far.
Matoka Warrior:
Is the high damage variety but has less mix potential, mostly relies on wiff punishing and proper footsies to get the cash out into oki setups with wolf buff armor/baited WU's.
Ancestrial Gift:
This is obviously the CMD Grab variation along with being the go to mix em up close its also amazing at counter zoning and shines where Matoka Warrior doesn't.
He is very mixup heavy in this variation and has so many options:
Staggers off:
B1
B13
3
31
312
So many mids that force them to respect his high staggers.
Combine this with his F2121, B13, B34/B341+3, & Throws/CMD Grabs he has a ton of mix that forces them to worry.
His 11 is an auto Shimmy and is easily done into the current meta Strike/Throw guess game but in his case its Strike/Throw-KB/Strike CMD Grab/Shimmy/Overhead-Low guess game. This is enough to overwhelm even the best of players.
Yes he gets about 20% off his conversions and throws but he does have good KB's that will do at least 30% like his:
- Throw KB (Front or Back)
- Rhino Charge Amp KB (Back Throw sets it up) you want to Wiff the mid and only connect the OH because it has a ten frame gap.
- 312 I find his CMD grab has enough hit adv to be at the range needed and 312 sets up 312 where only the last hit connects (perfect).
- D2 KB does above 25-30% even with none optimals into CMD Grab and gives +70 hit advantage into meaty guess game and possible KB.
Damage isn't the biggest deal, he can punish so many things, there are even gals in strings he can TP through and punish them wiffing including many projectiles. Think Cassie Yaas Queen was considered Top 5 by SonicFox and she only gets 19-23% on her midscreen combos.
But there are clear advantages to choosing AG over MW: mad mix, counter zoning, full screen presence, reset neutral at will, punish gaps Matoka can't and badass brutality and normals.
But I use (Matoka Warrior mainly because I love the corner carry and armor setups from wolf buff Not to mention damage. But I use (Ancestrial Gift) vs Cetrion, Liu Kang, Cassie, Sonya Ring Master, Sub Zero, Noob Saibot.
I feel both variations are very solid. And getting low damage isn't a reason not to use his CMD Grab version so many characters have low damage and are very strong: Jade, Scarlet, Cetrion, Cassie, Jax and Shang Spellmaster come to mind.