You're referring to the matchup chart threads in every character forum? To be fair that was THTB/Konqrr's idea before this "community chart by pro players only" thread even existed. Back then we didn't really have a plan, so Konqrr was just asking around for everyone's input and opinions on all matchups. So yeah it's pretty chaotic right now.
How about we do a dynamic tier list Shoryuken style?
http://bbr.s23.eatj.com/matchupper/
But again, only the top players of each character would be able to score their main character's chart. So in the end we just round up the numbers and have a pretty good average. That could work.