I'm really liking the breakdowns and insight you guys are giving. I think over the next few days to a week we'll really get to the bottom of this. Basically what we're seeing is some shifting placement within tiers for the most part, from the existing list.
Konqrr I agree on the Ermac/Smoke 6/4 over Kitana. A good number of the 5/5s I have listed are matches I couldn't really decide on a true winner based on my personal experience, but the set is definitely close.
Kitana/Classic Sub I agree
USub and Cyrax I still see more as a 7/3, not quite an 8/2 but perhaps it is, however USub RSmoke I can agree with. For Scorp/Sub, I'm still inclined to think the ice clone mixups can bait enough teleports to overshadow Scorpion's low damage, where H Smoke would dominate USub merely because of it.
I will go through and make some adjustments. Players keep looking over the chart and anything you see that you don't like, point it out over and over. Also the chart itself should be a bit easier to read now. I would like to eventually have a hover-over function when you point to a row, but I would like it to highlight a cross, up down and left right so it intersects over which characters you're comparing on hover. Could even do something goofy eventually with some game sprites where if you hover over a match up, the characters will be in a certain frame of animation comically dictating how good or bad the match up is.
Konqrr I agree on the Ermac/Smoke 6/4 over Kitana. A good number of the 5/5s I have listed are matches I couldn't really decide on a true winner based on my personal experience, but the set is definitely close.
Kitana/Classic Sub I agree
USub and Cyrax I still see more as a 7/3, not quite an 8/2 but perhaps it is, however USub RSmoke I can agree with. For Scorp/Sub, I'm still inclined to think the ice clone mixups can bait enough teleports to overshadow Scorpion's low damage, where H Smoke would dominate USub merely because of it.
I will go through and make some adjustments. Players keep looking over the chart and anything you see that you don't like, point it out over and over. Also the chart itself should be a bit easier to read now. I would like to eventually have a hover-over function when you point to a row, but I would like it to highlight a cross, up down and left right so it intersects over which characters you're comparing on hover. Could even do something goofy eventually with some game sprites where if you hover over a match up, the characters will be in a certain frame of animation comically dictating how good or bad the match up is.