Ive always felt like Akuma was a solid character. He's not top tier next to Balrog and such but he's really good. Shit healh of course, but the 25hp increase coming is a bigger deal than people think it is. I thought it was pointless, but Ive come around. Dont get me wrong, he's not suddenly jumping up tier lists over it, but its going to help him take rounds he wouldnt have otherwise taken. but he has good normals (if a little short) and lots and lots of option. I think he's fine and one of the better balanced characters in the game IN A PERFECT WORLD - and what I mean by that is that Akuma has a TON of power. Lots of options and lots of tools, but the player really has to think and understand whats going on to use them and make them powerful. Imo this is how characters should usually work, hence the in a perfect world.
Akuma isnt weak by any stretch. He's just a well balanced, strong character that's eclipsed by semi-unbalanced, hyper strong characters. Maybe I'm a scum bag, but I feel like he's a few notches lower than Karin, and Karin is right under the S tier characters.
I think Akuma is a pure skill character.. he wont carry you a single inch, so why the fuck would I play him? Dunno. I picked him up at release and played him the first month of S1 (or there-abouts) and really liked him, but wasnt comfortable with the low ass health.. Time on Karin though has gotten me used to it.
Also, just my own dumb opinion, but I think Akuma has great fireballs, just not a great fireball GAME.
Also, anyone play PoE?