Yes, this is why it's so surprising. Everyone finds it hard to believe.
It was even surprising for the commentator at NLBC.
He was constantly saying what you say: "Why isn't he punishing that? It's a scrub move".
By the end of the tournament he actually admitted that it's overpowered.
I guess this makes everyone down there at NLBC as scrubby as me, who didn't lab the matchup and just crybaby arround the forums right?
Ehhh hehhehehehehehhhhh
Video reference:
Mark 106:
Mark 3270:
Unfortunately for you guys it seems everyone knows the answer to the move: It's broken.