How is D4 broken or dumb? It's a poke that leads to other offence just like every other poke in the game. Mileena has the same D4 but noone says shit about her. Not to mention Kitana has a 6f D1 with the same range. Sure it doesn't cancel into anything, but at 6f, who cares? You can just whip that shit out as much as you please until you get bored and throw a Cutter in there.
Kartwheel is ast the same time the best tool and the biggest gimmick in the entire game. Yeah it's a safe launcher but it's easier than shit to hit her out of it after 20 frames. Hell, a simple jump kick will take her out of it (believe me I know the AI does that shit CONSTANTLY
).
And let's not forget that both moves can be baited and punished.
It really comes down to this: How many majors has Sonya won? How many minors? Other than the ones Death goes to, how many locals even has Sonya won? Exactly. Sonya isn't broken. People would rather whine than figure out how to beat her shit.
But, in an effort to get this thread back on track, I now think that the Sheeva players are the most downplaying of players. You guys need more faith in that 4-armed beast