You're not presenting an argument to debate. Literally read all those quotes. All you're essentially saying is that defensive play isn't the best option. The only other possible strategy you've proposed is feints/feint attacks. Feints by themselves are not an offensive move, they're for baiting. And fient attacks, where you cancel the heavy into another attack, while the best option for offense, is still not as good as defensive play. There's no downside to playing defensively as long as you have decent reactions and know the matchups. The risk reward factor for playing offensively against a good player is ridiculous compared to playing defensively against a good player. This isn't to say you can't have an effective offensive strategy or playstyle, but this does nothing to diminish the fact that defensive play is the best strat in the game.
"You're not presenting an argument to debate"
"All you're essentially saying is that defensive play isn't the best option"
Isn't that an argument
(you then proceed to debate my non argument)
Lets be clear here I never said that the best way to play was to play defensively or offensively I said that turtling is not the best way to play
Feints by themselves are not a defensive move either. Yes they are for baiting which is good vs defensive play.
"And fient attacks, where you cancel the heavy into another attack, while the best option for offense, is still not as good as defensive play. The risk reward factor for playing offensively against a good player is ridiculous compared to playing defensively against a good player." Firstly there is no giant risk for feint attacks and second they are not the best option for offense.