Awkward Sloth
Lamest Harley, still better sloth than Jer
I was excited to go over this list until I read that Crimson Shadow did the website/list and it really shows...For you or anyone else curious to know who were the top players in mk9, @CrimsonShadow 's http://mkirankings.com/ does a decent job of atleast providing a snapshot of the skill levels during the highest competitive era of mk9's life span which was around most of 2012 and beginning of 2013.
Data is missing from 2011 and most of 2013 but I think for the most part gives an accurate idea of atleast how good someone was in mk9's life span imo. Check out the top 50 and see how the times have changed from then.
Btw , I think the only things that matter for any ranking is consistency of tournament placements in relation to the competition at the tournament which includes the whole life span of the game. I think it is a little unfair to disregard tournaments for an all time ranking just because they happened during the first year of the game. Therefore my top 5 in no order is:
Sonic,
Forever King,
Pig of the Hut,
DJT,
Wound Cowboy
Honourable mentions:
Perfect Legend,
REO,
MIT
But thank you for the resource anyway. Hopefully I can go back and find archives of some of these tournaments on youtube and watch them there. The mlg stuff is usually harder to find tho.