NW's footsies don't matter if you can duck my mids, brah. As for CW WUs, Staff spin gets beat by Catscratch.
NW doesn't have any huge advantage over CW. Like you said there's no point in Escrima and my strengths in staff (zoning, range, decent WUs) are easily countered. Zoning gets blown up by Cat Dash, Range doesn't matter cause of your hitbox, and you can Neutral jump and punish all over my WUs.
Combine that with Catwoman's faster normals, slightly outdamaging NW, 50-50s and cause she can't jump in for free maybe, I can't see NW having an advantage.
5-5 Hold dat
Selina cannot duck his standing 2. That and ground pound are his main footsies tools. She doesn't duck his best moves.
She doesn't have infinite scratches. You only have to respect her wakeup if she has scratches. If she is neutral jumping NW on wakeup it means she's respecting his options. This is not what she wants to do. You can neutral jump her wakeup scratch, except she doesn't always have access to it.
She beats zoning on a read. Because GP is so fast it's not easy to get it out in time for the armor to be active. She has to guess and it's either punishable or he gets pressure when blocked.
Every Nightwing says the same thing and it's all a bill. "well I mean, you have options, you could jump a ground pound, you could duck a NW jump 2". True and you have options to cover those options. The point is Nightwing is the one in control. He is the one that dictates the footsies game. I want to hear something new not meta 1 bill's of goods like she ducks under the standing 1.