As a reminder, in terms of exclusive games, that's completely personal preference.
I own all major relevant systems, however, I purchased my PS4 later in the game, and I bought it second hand.
My Xbox One, I got the 2013 Day One Edition, even though I didn't agree with Microsoft's initial forcing of the Kinect, online check-in, and most egregious, the incredibly lower specs of the base model of the XB1 compared to the base model PS4.
The standouts for me were:
- Killer Instinct
- I prefer Forza Motorsport over Gran Turismo
- Forza Horizon (any version) is better than any current arcade/sim hybrid, hands down.
- I'm a Gears of War fan.
- Halo exclusives
- The xbox live online platform is still superior.
That said, I bought my PS4 in order to play MK on the mainstream "tournament" platform, which I knew would not be Xbox. I am also a fan of some Sony Exclusives such as:
Uncharted
Spiderman
The cost of my PS4 ($200 with 1 month of use on it), along with the base model PS4 running 3rd party games better then the base model XB1, plus the few Sony exclusives made it an easy choice to get it.
I have recently upgraded to an XB1X, and I rarely even touch my PS4. I buy and pre-order my games on XB1X, whereas I only wait for sales, discounts and specials to purchase games on my PS4.
Lastly, there is no better gaming deal these days than Xbox Game Pass Ultimate. $15 per month, hundreds of games, all Microsoft exclusives immediately (and what looks to be permanently) available for play the day of release, plus nearly all of those games are also available AT NO EXTRA COST to you on a moderately spec'd windows 10 gaming pc.
I will be getting both the XSX and PS5, but again, in the same order. I will get the base model XSX on day one, and the PS5 down the road, when it is less money, and likely second hand. I have numerous reasons for this, but the biggest ones are that nearly my entire Xbox library (from XB Classic, 360 and XB1) are backward compatible and will play on XSX on day one, along with the added Game Pass games available on day 1.
Microsoft and Nintendo have been pretty much all in on willingness to enable cross play. Sony had to be strong-armed into it and seems they still only do it begrudgingly.
Sony is still "testing" compatibility with their nearly 4,000 games. They have said that these games will be tested and released on a case by case basis.
I have never been a fan of Sony's business practices, especially since the days of the PS3. I appreciated the free PSN back then, but the removal of backward compatibility, along with forcing customers to re-purchase games they owned on previous Playstation platforms in order to play them again was, in my opinion, very shady. They even did it AGAIN with the PS4. Unless you had PSNow, your previous games didn't move forward to the PS4, you had to use a streaming service and hope they were available.
I believe MS has a much more forward thinking, customer friendly strategy with the XSX, and I believe that it goes beyond just the XSX. In case people aren't aware, here's a quick history lesson:
The X in Xbox stands for DirectX, as in the DirectX Infrastructure which is what all Xbox systems have employed from the XB Classic all the way to the upcoming XSX. This is why backward compatibility is just a white/black list of backward compatibility and not a port for the XB systems, whereas for Sony systems, they need to be ported.
MS is thinking beyond just the XSX. They believe that once you buy a game (similar to Steam), your game is your game and you should always have access to it and be able to play it, regardless of what Xbox system you now own.
Which FINALLY brings me to MS buying WB. If they do, remember that MS is a bit more liberal with licensing. I wouldn't be surprised to see MS allow WB games on other systems for a price. If that doesn't happen, then remember that if you don't have an XB1 or XSX, and MS buys WB, then you'll also have access to the PC versions as well as cross play with the consoles, which is becoming pretty standard with all XB1/Game Pass/Windows 10 releases.