Alright I really need help here. I've heard repeatedly that Batman beats Superman because he limits his mobility and then has a good enough upclose game.
But if I'm Batman, first off at the beginning of the round is Superman f23s, I have to block that. No normals are fast enough to beat that and just doing a raw parry is not worth the risk reward. So at the jump, disadvantage.
If Superman backs up I now have to go to him or throw bats. If I throw bats I'm creating distance between him and me, not what I want to do. From full screen Superman can really do what he wants. Grounded lasers, air lasers, ground lasers etc until he has bar for a mb. Meanwhile I'm trying to inch my way forward and any counter bats I throw push me backward.
Mid screen is the toss up. I'm close enough that Superman can jump for the air laser read then air dash forward for a j2 f23 combo, or dash backwards for more air lasers or just neutral jump and make me pause expecting something. Regardless mid screen there's control. Unless I'm making a hard read on it Batman is not in the lead here either. I can have trait out but trait's only useful on reaction to Superman's offense. I release them preemptively and lose them or they track badly. Not to mention a conversion off them isn't even gurateneed. Some pressure yes but if I didn't take a hit this entire time, I maybe have a single bar. Maybe.
By the time I'm close enough to use buttons I'm already in f23 range where I don't have the ability to challenge him. His normals are too fast. My normals are all negative enough that a d1 can challenge without much fear even with bats out. Block f23 breath, now it's time for a guessing game where throughout the entire game Batman does not have the offense. He is defensively guessing Superman's offense. Assuming I managed to get trait out and keep it at this point, this is when I'd have the biggest chance to get something started but that's a lot of ifs.
Throughout this entire situation unless I hard read a mb grapple or up bat or mb upbat I don't see how Batman is going even let alone winning this MU. So someone help me out here. I don't understand what makes Batman win this MU outside of people just over respecting his pressure.