SEV
Apprentice
I find that a lot of people in this community up play this character a lot. Now let me first state that I do believe he has the tools of a typical top 5 character: reaching frame traps, 50/50's that can confirm into 50%+ combos, an amazing D2, the best forward dash in the game probably, the ability to punish with Lightning Charge, and the ability to completely avoid all interactibles with Speed Dodge; however, in order for Flash to be top 5, that means that there can only be four characters better than him.
The phrase "top 5" has become more synonymous with a figurative meaning more so than its literal meaning when it comes to IGAU, describing cast members that have the tools to be considered within the top 5. The cast members that are generally considered for this are:
Black Adam
Superman
Aquaman
Wonder Woman
Martian Man Hunter
Batman
Zod
Green Lantern
Batgirl
Flash
Doomsday
Killer Frost
These are the cast members that are widely accepted to be within the top tiers as of now, and in my opinion are top 5 material; twelve characters. So again, in order for the Flash to be in the top 5, there can only be four cast members that rank higher.
Although the Flash does have solid tools, does he have something better than Black Adam's back dash? Something better than Superman's F23? Something better than Aquaman's combo breaking trait? Is he a better rounded character than Wonder Woman? Are his set ups and punishes better than Martian Man Hunter's? Can he pressure better than Batman? Are is mix-ups as legit as Zod's? Are his midscreen set ups better than Green Lantern's OTG resets? Can his standing meterless vortex even compare with Batgirl's?
Now I believe everyone is entitled to their opinion, but I can not fathom how you can come to form the opinion that he is within the top 5 over other characters. The list above is my top 12, in that order. I think the case could be made to switch Batgirl and Flash around but I don't see the Flash being any higher than 9th as of now and can be as low as 12th behind Doomsday and/or Killer Frost depending on your argument.
I feel the Flash is still being slept on to an extent due to limited Flash players in the community which has led to a widespread misconception of this character's placement in the tier lists. Barry is a solid character, but I just don't believe that an argument can be made that is strong enough to convince me that he is top 5.
The phrase "top 5" has become more synonymous with a figurative meaning more so than its literal meaning when it comes to IGAU, describing cast members that have the tools to be considered within the top 5. The cast members that are generally considered for this are:
Black Adam
Superman
Aquaman
Wonder Woman
Martian Man Hunter
Batman
Zod
Green Lantern
Batgirl
Flash
Doomsday
Killer Frost
These are the cast members that are widely accepted to be within the top tiers as of now, and in my opinion are top 5 material; twelve characters. So again, in order for the Flash to be in the top 5, there can only be four cast members that rank higher.
Although the Flash does have solid tools, does he have something better than Black Adam's back dash? Something better than Superman's F23? Something better than Aquaman's combo breaking trait? Is he a better rounded character than Wonder Woman? Are his set ups and punishes better than Martian Man Hunter's? Can he pressure better than Batman? Are is mix-ups as legit as Zod's? Are his midscreen set ups better than Green Lantern's OTG resets? Can his standing meterless vortex even compare with Batgirl's?
Now I believe everyone is entitled to their opinion, but I can not fathom how you can come to form the opinion that he is within the top 5 over other characters. The list above is my top 12, in that order. I think the case could be made to switch Batgirl and Flash around but I don't see the Flash being any higher than 9th as of now and can be as low as 12th behind Doomsday and/or Killer Frost depending on your argument.
I feel the Flash is still being slept on to an extent due to limited Flash players in the community which has led to a widespread misconception of this character's placement in the tier lists. Barry is a solid character, but I just don't believe that an argument can be made that is strong enough to convince me that he is top 5.