This is such a poor argument and I hate when people do shit like this
I’m in no way saying jacqui is broken or whatever the case may be, but the fact that Bio beat some jacqui players doesn’t automatically mean she’s not broken
Kabal was broken af in MK9 and he was beaten plenty of times
Same case with MMH in I1
Tanya and Alien
Deadshot
Those characters were prime examples of top tier/broken and yet they’ve still been beaten at high-level play. So if Jacqui is busted, that doesn’t mean she’s unbeatable. It just showed that Bio outplayed them
I think what you're not getting is that Dave and I aren't just speaking to tiers; we're talking about people who literally don't know the matchup, and are crying before even learning it.
I have no problem with someone who knows the matchup well discussing why it's easy or hard.
I said this in the other thread, but if you didn't actually know how to fight MK9 Kabal -- meaning that if you didn't understand how NDC pressure works, or how to get through zoning -- you have no right to assess how bad you think a MU is just because you heard he was impossible to beat. Learn the MU first, and then you have a platform to complain.
So specifically with Upgraded, I'm seeing people who don't know how to contest/punish Bounce and Air Blast Cancel complain that it's virtually unblockable and the character should be completely removed from the game. Meanwhile people who are actually taking the time to learn how Upgraded works are beating the best representatives of that variation repeatedly.
So the point is, if you're going to cry bloody murder about a MU, at least learn how to play it first. And if people are countering it successfully, learn from that, and then use that to assess how strong the character really is.
If you can't agree with that, I don't know what to say.