They're not bad movies, and people who listen soley to critics are idiots who can't judge something for themselves. BvS was hated by critics not everyone though, and MOS was mixed in general literally.
Let's put it this way, listening to a "critic" is as bad as listening to the mainstream media regarding who to vote for because a certain network said so....
They're not bad. Watch Fantastic Four, that's BAD.....as in actually bad, hardly made money, shitty CGI, shitty plot, acting everything.
I agree about critics, I rarely read them, and when I do its mostly out of curiosity, never guide myself by them. And agree as well with the media and the voters, completely.
I hate the fantastic four since I was a child, so I never watched any of the movies, I am not surprised everyone says they are bad, but I havent had the displeasure of watching them. But, to answer to this point still, I would say I don't think BvS is the worst movie ever, but It is still a bad movie. If I had to describe it with only one word I would probably say "Dull".
Now, you can like it anyway. I mean, I dont, but I like plenty of other movies that are really bad, Star Wars as the biggest offender probably, sometimes it is hard believing how bad it is, but I still like.
Out of curiosity, which characters didn't you like the NRS interpretation of?
I was pretty happy with all of them, since it seems they used the JL cartoon as a template.
I don't know that could really merge Bane in with Doomsday. I get that you are not saying that, but trying to explain what Ryu is saying...but I don't see it. Their traits are very different, and thus they play very differently.
Sure, you could get rid of Bane, but I think the way he plays fits into the game very well, and is very distinctive from the way DD plays....just my 2c. I really can't imagine them being merged or consolidated. in anyway that wouldn't detract.
Know that I don't know that much about comics, so my opinion is of little relevance here:
Black Adam and Zattana, I think they are the only ones I truly didn't like the interpretaition NRS made, I liked playing as them, I just didn't think their gameplay was true to the characters. Then there are others where I don't think it was bad, just think it could've been done better, like Superman, Deathstroke, Hal, or Sinestro, for example.
And yes, Bane and Doomsday play very diferently, but if NRS had decided to remove Bane from the game and give that moveset to Doomsday instead (and call the trait something like "Rage" instead of vemon), it would have been a poorly executed DD, one that is not very true to his character, but it would still have worked, because DD CAN do anything Bane does. I think that is the idea, I think.
I don't think that is the way it should be done. Because of rosters are not chosen only by the characters unique abilities but by popularity and demand, there will be tons of times where characters powers and skills overlap, and there is were the desing comes, and where the team has to do their best to diferenciate said characters while keeping the gameplay true to them, to their style and personality.