I mean honestly, it's not like it really matters what counter points get posted, it's not going to change you guys' minds on anything.
Martian Manhunter destroyed her as did Hawkgirl and Wonder Woman among others( Bane, Cyborg, Black Adam to name a few also gave her trouble).
Her interactable presence was a joke and she was so insanely reliant on slide that she struggled heavily against characters who didn't have to play around her at all via their good air presence, air normals or air mobility and that list was quite extensive.
The reason why people mention her match ups and how she performs in them is because listing a bunch of good tools doesn't tell the actual story about the character.
I can list a bunch of great tools for Catwoman, great oki, safe mix ups, low profiling combo launcher, long ranged jump normals etc, but how does she do in match ups? A characters can have on paper good tools, but still struggle in the meta due to their match up chart.
If she is mid tier, she's on the lower end. The idea of top ten being posted was my initial reason for commenting because that's just not realistic. I dunno why anybody is bothered by that, but she's not top ten in the current meta of the game and I don't think there's too many people who actually believe she's better than the previous characters I mentioned.
I also think it's odd because the purpose of discussion is not to "win", but to understand and be understood. I'm not weighing in for any other reason than to inform. The idea that Killer Frost doesn't lose AT ALL to Hawkgirl is one of the many reasons why I'm posting because that's not based on a reasonable analysis of the tools available to Hawkgirl and Killer Frost.
