What's new

Question Is Tom Brady a top 10 player?

EGP Wonder_Chef

Official Quan Chi Nerf Demander™
I didn't ignore Texas, showtime was at NEC. I am just not going to pretend that Scar, and CAT placed extraordinary well at dallas, they got what top 16 which I think Tyrant got too. Mit and and DJT are that difficult of comp to make Dallas way much harder tournament than NEC, than every local tyrant placed higher then them I want to be counted as tournament win.
I really can't argue with your logic.

Like it is impossible.
 

REO

Undead
While I do agree with this, the general idea of being a top player is based on results, and if you want great results, then you're better off using the best character in the game than if you were to use a character like Sheeva.
Hence why this is not a true competitive game if only one character can win at the highest level. Kabal should be banned so we can attract players from other gaming communities or allow players who main low tiers to have the confidence to attend tourneys now.
 

CrimsonShadow

Administrator and Community Engineer
Administrator
Okay, Tom, riu, death, and especially sonicfox are playing light years ahead of PL, Madzin, and gross right now. Blake good player but I am sorry flopped at dallas. That just leaves with the WC who tyrant competes with all the time, and Pig/CDsr/Dizzy. I still feel Tyrant placing at NEC is = the same amount of props if he got top 8 at dallas.
Wait. Haha. This is so wrong, I don't even know where to start. Tom, riu, death and sonic fox are playing better than PerfectLegend? Didn't PL just get 2nd at SB:A -- When's the last time any of those guys made 2nd place at a tournament with Dizzy, CD Jr., M2Dave, and Slips there? And how is any tournament that's missing Pig, Dizzy, MIT, PL, and Denzel harder than one that has all of them?

Good gracious.

I'm just going to quietly step away. You've got this one, Wonder_Chef ;)
 

Pig Of The Hut

Day 0 Phenomenal Dr. Fate and Darkseid player
wow, okay one bad MU whoopie di doo, you sure do have alot of uphill battles don't you pig, and the funny thing is even with a character good as kenshi you don't even play him 100 percent in tournament. How do I know you really know kenshi MU's and don't give me that "I play super serious casuals with so and so 8 clock in morning before the tournament", or XBL.
you dummy he has more than 4
 
There was a lot of talk during the MLG season if Tom Brady was still a top player. Since he couldn't compete many considered him washed up but others pointed to his success and quality wins at smaller grass roots tournaments as proof he'd be a contender at MLG if he was able to compete. Now he is back and has placed top 8 at one of the biggest tournaments of the year. Should Tom be considered a top 10 player now?

Here are the facts...

NEC had more entrants than any of the MLG events.

All of the usual suspects were there with few exceptions(Terry bros, Dizzy, Pig).

It was worth 1,000 points on NFG.

Tom lost to his first opponent with Johnny Cage and then made it all the way through losers with only Sub-Zero.

Tom overcame multiple 3-7 MU back to back.

Tom defeated two MLG top 8 finalists back to back to place.




Discuss.
Imagine if Tom played Kabal first instead of Sub. Imagine that encyclopedic knowledge and borderline insurmountable match-up knowledge with a top 5 character. No one would stand a chance. Tom is a top 5 PLAYER stuck with a bottom 10 CHARACTER.
 
PL is washed up, He flopped at dallas. SB wasn't even real major PL will tell you that himself, but so what it had 37 players of which 7 were solid players, and dizzy still mopped the floor with him. His kabal is awful and 16bit mashed his head in. I see no reason why those 4 players today are not playing better than PL. TBH I don't think PL would of even made it out of pools at NEC.
 

CrimsonShadow

Administrator and Community Engineer
Administrator
PL is washed up, He flopped at dallas. SB wasn't even real major PL will tell you that himself, but so what it had 37 players of which 7 were solid players, and dizzy still mopped the floor with him. His kabal is awful and 16bit mashed his head in. I see no reason why those 4 players today are not playing better than PL. TBH I don't think PL would of even made it out of pools at NEC.
Checkmate. You just sunk your boat. If PL is "washed up" because he 'flopped' at Dallas, and he placed the same as Tyrant as Dallas.. Well you do the math. Apparently placing the same as Tyrant means you're washed up and your career as a top player is over.

If he wouldn't have made it out of pools at NEC beacuse he had one not-so-great tourney at Dallas, then I guess Tyrant shouldn't have either.

Oh, wait.
 
Hence why this is not a true competitive game if only one character can win at the highest level. Kabal should be banned so we can attract players from other gaming communities or allow players who main low tiers to have the confidence to attend tourneys now.
Banning him wouldn't necessarily bring in newcomers though. People have hated on MK since before Kabal was undoubtedly number 1.
 
Checkmate. You just sunk your boat. If PL is "washed up" because he 'flopped' at Dallas, and he placed the same as Tyrant as Dallas.. Well you do the math.

If he wouldn't have made it out of pools at NEC beacuse he had one not-so-great tourney at Dallas, then I guess Tyrant shouldn't have either.

Oh, wait.
Tyrant lost to jax absolute worst MUs, 7-3s, not cause he played like shit like PL did. PL got bodied by Dab cage LOL, and than man handled by MIT liu kang jumping from character to character not having a single clue what to do in the entire set. I think you need to rewatch PL at dallas and than his matches with blake the next day, and then his kabal vs 16bit. PL is playing like TRASH right now, I am 100 percent certain Riu, Death, Tom, and sonikfawk are playing better than PL is right now.
 

Pig Of The Hut

Day 0 Phenomenal Dr. Fate and Darkseid player
The character you use should have some consequence on this list. For example, since I play Kabal who gives a shit if I do well or win a tournament because it's Kabal. I don't think I should be top ten players because when I don't use Kabal I don't get results, thus I'm not consistent and I'm more character than player ability. Players who place by using low tiers like SonicFox and Tom Brady should gain extra stock and respect because it shows true skill more than the top characters. Just my two cents.
 

Pig Of The Hut

Day 0 Phenomenal Dr. Fate and Darkseid player
Maan, Jax has real bad MU's. Take some notes from are community great character specialist and grind some MU's out. For fuck sake you thought cage vs kenshi was even, and that sindel beat kenshi.
You are right but Ive since stopped being a pussy and owned my mistakes
 

Pig Of The Hut

Day 0 Phenomenal Dr. Fate and Darkseid player
Checkmate. You just sunk your boat. If PL is "washed up" because he 'flopped' at Dallas, and he placed the same as Tyrant as Dallas.. Well you do the math. Apparently placing the same as Tyrant means you're washed up and your career as a top player is over.

If he wouldn't have made it out of pools at NEC beacuse he had one not-so-great tourney at Dallas, then I guess Tyrant shouldn't have either.

Oh, wait.
**note to self**

Do not play chess w Crimson Shadow, Mother f'er is bad ass
 

Pig Of The Hut

Day 0 Phenomenal Dr. Fate and Darkseid player
Tyrant lost to jax absolute worst MUs, 7-3s, not cause he played like shit like PL did. PL got bodied by Dab cage LOL, and than man handled by MIT liu kang jumping from character to character not having a single clue what to do in the entire set. I think you need to rewatch PL at dallas and than his matches with blake the next day, and then his kabal vs 16bit. PL is playing like TRASH right now, I am 100 percent certain Riu, Death, Tom, and sonikfawk are playing better than PL is right now.
Oh cool 3 sonya players against PL , and you were talking about bad MU for jax how about realizing bad MUs for Lao
 
Oh cool 3 sonya players against PL , and you were talking about bad MU for jax how about realizing bad MUs for Lao
THERE IS NO WAY lao vs sonya is = jax vs sonya, and that lao vs cage = jax vs cage. Also come on PL got bodied by dab cage when he use KABAL. Also that doesn't explain the beaten that MIT gave him. Come on man, PL might be worst player in the community right now. Did you see his kabal?
 
1. PL is not washed up. Just because someone doesnt qualify at one event doesnt mean washed up.

2. REO wins because hes a great player. The character has 0.0% to do with how good someone should be seen. What makes someone great is what they do with their ability. Being top from day 1 and winning several BIG majors is why REO is considered great, has nothing to do with Kabal nor should he be penalized because of his choice of character. I only wish that people would stop thinking its Kabal and realize that REO has accomplished so much because of his abilities and not his choice of character.
 

Pig Of The Hut

Day 0 Phenomenal Dr. Fate and Darkseid player
THERE IS NO WAY lao vs sonya is = jax vs sonya, and that lao vs cage = jax vs cage. Also come on PL got bodied by dab cage when he use KABAL. Also that doesn't explain the beaten that MIT gave him. Come on man, PL might be worst player in the community right now. Did you see his kabal?
yea and his pocket kabal got 17th at dallas w tyrant main jax

#checkmate been practicing chess w crimson shadow
 

TotteryManx

cr. HP Master
Fine, but, tyrant redeemed himself at NEC while PL got bodied even worst by 16bit. PL is god awful these days, he will never win again quote me on that too.
I will definitely remember this. He will win FF...quote me on that as well. Also, I believe Tom Brady is indeed a top 10 player. Over the complete life span of MK9 he didn't finish top 8 like twice or something. Says a lot, especially when you're battling Kabals and Kenshis with Subby.
 
@Tom Brady this guy lol. . . you guys would need to play this guy for as long as i have to understand how good of a player
he is. to be honest i am not even surprise when he does good against a bad matchup because this is what years of experience
of been a top player does to your game