What's new

Question - Outlaw How good is Erron Black still?

wsj515

This is my billionth life cycle.
This character embodies everything I find wrong with MKX. He is ridiculously good and I can safely say that he is in the top 5. He is a better grappler than grappling characters and has better rushdown than rush down characters. Ridiculous meterless damage, best tick throw options in the game (forget about trying to defend against it online). One of the best nj punches in the game. He may not be that bad to top players but from the viewpoint of someone who's played everyday at an above average level against a pretty good Erron Black he is incredibly good and completely outshines both of my mains (Cutthroat/Cyber Kano and Unstoppable/Relentless Jason) in almost every aspect. So yeah he's pretty good.
Threw up in my mouth a little bit reading this post.
 

I GOT HANDS

Official Infrared Scorp wid gapless Wi-Fi pressure
Very solid character. Not broken, just got tools, and a good player can take advantage of his options and go very far with this character
 

SaJa

FH_FenriR
To me he is mid+ but he is also the hardest character to play in term of execution (not metagame) which makes him even harder (don't get stress/delay in tournament with dat char lol).

He has one of the best string in the game : 21122 (the first hit is high and won't connect after a bf3 ex because you can duck), which won't make him shit tier, but if you know the matchup, Erron Black isn't that good, especially after the multi-nerf patch. The character has always been overated because of Sonicfox, but I don't know if we are going to see the cowboy being top 8 that much from now. Outlaw may be still pretty good with the OS.

I main him for the very beginning now, I have some secondary (Tanya, Kotal, Kenshi, Torr, Goro, Shinnok, Dvorah) that I play time to time and I feel like my Erron Black is one of the weakiest of my cast (It was weird to me as well) once people figured out the mu.

Offline you can armor him in reaction on the overhead (f1). I really think this character is overated. His d3 command grab doesn't connect anymore (I believed Erron Black was a grabber...), his pokes have a very short range, his backdash is awfull, his command grab is now useless in BnB, his zoning is limited (bf3) in most matchups, in Outlaw he had a particular neutral jump punch due to his variation but NRS nerfed it while Kung Jin, Quanchi and Raiden still got theirs in an universal way.

Gunslinger could answer to bad matchups but it's not even viable without changes patch by now.

When all the other shit char will be buff (and they will), I think Erron Black will have hard(er) time. I may be wrong but this is how I feel it. I see everyone dropping him, and despite Sonicfox (who's pretty skilled), I haven't seen him shined that much in tournament.

However, Erron Black stays the funniest char to play in the game.

@xGunShow @HeroesNZ did you drop him ? What do you think ?
 
Last edited:

wsj515

This is my billionth life cycle.
Erron Black is the Smoke of MKX
From reading your first post, it is very clear you just don't know the matchup. You are not an above average player if you know the matchup and still cannot read and punish a tick throw or ex SG within 21122. Furthermore, saying his meterless damage is ridiculous is, well, ridiculous.

I feel like people are not willing to lab matchups any more, there's got to be a reason why people still think EB is top 3, or how people STILL think the mixup in the 21122 string is grab or ex SG when both are full combo punishable by a forward jump.
 

SaJa

FH_FenriR
Nah he's still my main - he's probably still top 10.

Any character with safe 50/50s in this game can't be that bad.
Every character in the game got safe 50/50, kind of, because all Erron's black string are punishable.
 

NoobSaibot

PSN: JP_THUNDA
From reading your first post, it is very clear you just don't know the matchup. You are not an above average player if you know the matchup and still cannot read and punish a tick throw or ex SG within 21122. Furthermore, saying his meterless damage is ridiculous is, well, ridiculous.

I feel like people are not willing to lab matchups any more, there's got to be a reason why people still think EB is top 3, or how people STILL think the mixup in the 21122 string is grab or ex SG when both are full combo punishable by a forward jump.
I feel like you don't understand how retarded it is that at several points in one string you can cancel into throw, sand storm, grenade, or slide. Or just finish the string and blow me up for guessing wrong. It has nothing to do with making a read its a guessing game, which is retarded. Punishing a wiffed throw is easy and that wasn't the point of or even mentioned in my first post. Every time I talk about how lop sided this match up is for Kano there's always the "you just suck, make better reads" comment. I have fought a damn good outlaw Erron Black everyday since day 1 so your gonna have to come up with something better than just saying I suck at the game.
 

Smoke_Of_Finland

Believe in the hop kick
No matter what they take away this character will always remain top 10. You can talk about footsies and punishment all you want but EB still has more offensive bullshit than any other character in the game.
 
I'm seeing allot of "I think he is top 10 still" or "I play Erron Black so I'm going to say he is in top 3". What I am not seeing is facts, matches, lab work, statistics, etc. Even from respect tournament goers, and I don't mean to put everyone on blast but it would be helpful if we only stated factual infermation and not guesses. We all know he got hit with the Nerf stick, so where in the Top 20 dose Erron Black stand? Get to your labs!
 

wsj515

This is my billionth life cycle.
I feel like you don't understand how retarded it is that at several points in one string you can cancel into throw, sand storm, grenade, or slide. Or just finish the string and blow me up for guessing wrong. It has nothing to do with making a read its a guessing game, which is retarded. Punishing a wiffed throw is easy and that wasn't the point of or even mentioned in my first post. Every time I talk about how lop sided this match up is for Kano there's always the "you just suck, make better reads" comment. I have fought a damn good outlaw Erron Black everyday since day 1 so your gonna have to come up with something better than just saying I suck at the game.
It's really not that crazy, and it's erron's main dirt. Other characters get much better damage, much better 50/50 string options, much better oki, and much better pressure. I will say this one last time: it makes literally no difference what erron cancels into during the 21122 string, the mixup comes from WHEN. Then you make a read (oh I'm sorry "guess," because using braincells to deduce your opponent's tendencies is stupid) and full combo punish. I'm not going to even go into the fact that the first hit is high or that its really easy beat out with spacing. At the end of the day, just because your main has a bad matchup doesn't mean the character is broken, but the way you are complaining about it sounds like there is a lot more at work than just a bad matchup, you might just be a worse player than that erron, or you just refuse to adapt/actually learn the matchup
 

wsj515

This is my billionth life cycle.
He is right about the grapple part though
What grapple part? Tick throw off d3 has been removed, and 21122 is literally what differentiates EB from other characters. Let's also ignore the fact that it is full combo punishable on the correct read of when something will be canceled
 

xGunShow

Toronto, Canada @GunShowXO
To me he is mid+ but he is also the hardest character to play in term of execution (not metagame) which makes him even harder (don't get stress/delay in tournament with dat char lol).

He has one of the best string in the game : 21122 (the first hit is high and won't connect after a bf3 ex because you can duck), which won't make him shit tier, but if you know the matchup, Erron Black isn't that good, especially after the multi-nerf patch. The character has always been overated because of Sonicfox, but I don't know if we are going to see the cowboy being top 8 that much from now. Outlaw may be still pretty good with the OS.

I main him for the very beginning now, I have some secondary (Tanya, Kotal, Kenshi, Torr, Goro, Shinnok, Dvorah) that I play time to time and I feel like my Erron Black is one of the weakiest of my cast (It was weird to me as well) once people figured out the mu.

Offline you can armor him in reaction on the overhead (f1). I really think this character is overated. His d3 command grab doesn't connect anymore (I believed Erron Black was a grabber...), his pokes have a very short range, his backdash is awfull, his command grab is now useless in BnB, his zoning is limited (bf3) in most matchups, in Outlaw he had a particular neutral jump punch due to his variation but NRS nerfed it while Kung Jin, Quanchi and Raiden still got theirs in an universal way.

Gunslinger could answer to bad matchups but it's not even viable without changes patch by now.

When all the other shit char will be buff (and they will), I think Erron Black will have hard(er) time. I may be wrong but this is how I feel it. I see everyone dropping him, and despite Sonicfox (who's pretty skilled), I haven't seen him shined that much in tournament.

However, Erron Black stays the funniest char to play in the game.

@xGunShow @HeroesNZ did you drop him ? What do you think ?
I believe Erron Black is still a Top 10 Character. The reason I don't play him as much anymore is the lack of air control. Jumping attacks are very strong in this game and EB doesn't have a lot of options when it comes to this. His D2 is alright but other than his NJP in Outlaw, you don't have much. His best option is the Anti-Air Sand Bomb that has a start-up of 19F and can't be done on reaction.

EB is strongest when the opponent is grounded, but since jumping is prioritized (low risk, high reward) and so strong in this Game, it can be tough to deal with a lot of match ups.

Regardless, he has a great toolset which includes some of the best offense in the game and great mix-ups. Top 10 imo.
 

NoobSaibot

PSN: JP_THUNDA
It's really not that crazy, and it's erron's main dirt. Other characters get much better damage, much better 50/50 string options, much better oki, and much better pressure. I will say this one last time: it makes literally no difference what erron cancels into during the 21122 string, the mixup comes from WHEN. Then you make a read (oh I'm sorry "guess," because using braincells to deduce your opponent's tendencies is stupid) and full combo punish. I'm not going to even go into the fact that the first hit is high or that its really easy beat out with spacing. At the end of the day, just because your main has a bad matchup doesn't mean the character is broken, but the way you are complaining about it sounds like there is a lot more at work than just a bad matchup, you might just be a worse player than that erron, or you just refuse to adapt/actually learn the matchup
You do realize reads and guesses are two different things right? Maybe you just do the same cancel at the same time over and over but any good player isn't gonna do the same thing over and over. The second you start catching on they're gonna cancel into different things at different times. And yea there's definitely better characters in the game, not sure where I said he was the best, but he's still really damn good. Its ridiculous the amount of downplaying people are doing because he got a nerf. If you think he's not that good than switch characters. Try Kano out than talk to me about having to use brain cells.
 

wsj515

This is my billionth life cycle.
You do realize reads and guesses are two different things right? Maybe you just do the same cancel at the same time over and over but any good player isn't gonna do the same thing over and over. The second you start catching on they're gonna cancel into different things at different times. And yea there's definitely better characters in the game, not sure where I said he was the best, but he's still really damn good. Its ridiculous the amount of downplaying people are doing because he got a nerf. If you think he's not that good than switch characters. Try Kano out than talk to me about having to use brain cells.
Reads and guesses are not entirely different at all, but I don't feel like trying to explain that if you don't already understand it. I am not downplaying at all - the 21122 string is extremely strong, but it can be dealt with and punished hard and its obvious that you just don't know how to. You just keep complaining about the only stand out aspect of EB's game, 21122, while ignoring the glaring holes in his game and the fact that a lot of other characters do a lot of the same things that he does but better. EB is probably top 10, but definitely not safely top 5 as you say.

btw, I do in fact play Kano, and there's a lot Kano can do in the EB matchup. Its clear to me that the EB you play is just straight up better than you, no shame in that. Might help if you actually learned how to punish 21122 though, which Kano can do in a bunch of ways.