WannabePlayer
I can't test right now, but you shouldn't be able to jump out. I've never specifically tested, but holding up is easy to do and I've failed to jump out a ton of times during real matches. I'd guess your timing on f23 is off.
Record f23~breath, f23 and try using Ares 112 or 22 to get out. If it works at all it means your timing wasn't tight enough on the loop. It's pretty hard to get a solid loop recorded because ever since the breath nerf there seems to be different recovery on hit and block and you can't set the dummy to block while you're recording. So you'll record something that seems good but then get a bunch of stance switchs(2+3 is the macro for stance switch) and dumb stuff like that when you play it back.
Once you get a recording that you can't use Ares stand 1 to get out of, then you know you're accurate within a frame or two and can try other stuff.
It's much easier to test with two people, but then you have to repeat a ton of times to make sure things work or don't work consistently and aren't a result of human error