Wigy
There it is...
I don't think sub is top 5 this is maybe why he isn't performing but he is completely flowchart, he has to make half the reads most of the cast do. In the corner his 50/50s are safe since if you try punish you get caught in the clone.I wouldn't say he has complete air control but his j3 air to air is very good. There's other characters that can contend in the air to air game. I don't think fbc being easy is a great reason to call the character braindead as well. If he could just control the neutral game risk free I'd agree with you but by those standards I think a lot of things in this game can be considered braindead.
As for sub in grandmaster, he does have a general goal. Move the oppenent to the corner and keep them there but reads and etc come into play big time, especially in certain match ups. If it was as easy as going by a flowchart I'd think we would see a lot more successful sub zeros. Again though we can all make the argument that a lot of characters want to put you into certain situations where they choose between a few options. I always looked at a flowchart as more of a player style than a character design.
Scorpion gets about a bar and 12% chip at the end of every combo, and a 50/50 from F2 and B3string which are both safe, one leading to a HKD and the other to a 12ish percent string or he can just go for a grab. Considering how easy the cancel is..thats fucking stupid. Not to mention 40% 1 bar combos.
They are both designed as starter characters, however they are both really good for how easy they are to play.
Also both are not great matchups for all my characters.