You guys have to remember, these matchups are played at the "best possible/maximum level"
While I don't agree with some of the matchups (like sub-zero, sindel's)
Most of this is pretty accurate.
Yes, Kitana can beat a reptile, but go up against Chris G,
THTB, Snips, etc, trust me, kitana loses that MU.
I have recently accepted the fact that reptile is a bad MU for her.
You can't expect to read Kitana vs Nightwolf -5-5, then go online and beat a decent a Nightwolf, and claim it's 6.5-3.5
Nightwolf seems low tier, then you have @Lordofthefly make him look like a threat.
I pretty much agree with all the numbers Kitana has gotten, I still think shes an amazing character, but she suffers vs people who can keep her out, since she has no immediate armor on an ex move (other than the horizontal part of her ex boost, which is unreliable at times)