Pig: "Shouldn't Superman have like 150-160% health instead of 200% because of all the tools and damage output he has?"
PL: "No."
Pig: "Why?"
PL: "Because HE'S SUPERMAN."
gtfo with that shit lol. We're talking about game design and balance not stupid DC portrayal accuracy. Otherwise you can say: Hey, he's Superman. So you know what he should be the only character in the game with 100% combos and a third life bar. lol no.
Also let's get something clear: Akuma has low health in SF because he's so strong HE HAS TO HOLD HIMSELF BACK to have any challenge at all. Doesn't that remind you guys of a super hero? Just saying lol.
That said, I disagree with Pig when he says "all the top tiers" should get health reduction. If you reduce the health of a character like Killer Frost, she's going to have problems because she already has bad mobility, few options in general and deals weak damage. So having low health in addition to those already existing weaknesses wouldn't make sense. Black Adam and Superman having lower health would make sense because of their superior mobility and overall lack of weaknesses. So I definitely agree that it could be a solution but not a perfect solution.
At the same time, I feel like Pig is on to something just because his solution would keep the characters metagame intact and dumb, but they just wouldn't be AS DUMB and as dominating.
Like m2dave pointed out, Akuma, Yun and Seth have low health but they're still top tier characters because of the superior tools/options, mobility and vortexes they have. BUT, imagine Akuma, Yun and Seth with 1100 health? We also can't say starting with lower health doesn't matter because it does. If Akuma or Seth had 1100 starting health they would be ban worthy lbsh. Them starting with 850-750 hp basically just makes them "reasonable top tiers" as opposed to ridiculous god tier.
But I also agree with 16-Bit and Claude when they say the top 6-7 characters in Injustice just have really dumb tools that they shouldn't really have in the first place. I agree that all the exciting matches are during pools and when you get to top 8 it's just typical Superman, Black Adam, Batman, Green Lantern and they're some of the easiest to play and most boring to watch characters in the game. I mean you know a top 8 sucks when you're rooting for Chris G LOL.
I don't know, it's a tough call. I personally don't know how to really balance Injustice the right way. I don't know what they could change to make the matches more hype and make some of the top characters less boring/irritating to fight against. I honestly have no clue. But yes in general I agree that the top 6-7 characters could use either a health or damage nerf at the very least and some tweaks to frame data to at least be negative enough on block if not punishable on some things.