I think the only REAL way to do this is to take the top 5 players from every single major game and have them compete at other games. IMO, Justin Wong doing great at a 2D fighter does not automatically mean one game or scene is superior. And Chris G is another gamer who seems to be good at all 2D fighters as well.
I really like the MMA comparison.
Someone who practices wrestling, brazilian jiu-jitsu and kick-boxing and does well in every area is in theory clearly better than someone who only does boxing, but you can see that the person is talented.
If the MMA fighter tries to box against the boxer, he will probably lose, because he is not as on point as the boxer. But if the boxer tries to try himself in MMA, he will get blown up.
For now everyone hypes that boxer up, saying that he is so talented and the best fighter in the world, but he does not have anything to back it up. He has never proven it in wrestling. He has never proven it in brazilian jiu-jitsu and he has never proven it in kick-boxing, while there are many MMA artist who do all that and are consistent.
I am not a stupid person. I understand why people here are butthurt and calling me a troll. As a matter of fact, I troll all the time, but right now I don't. Right now I'm saying that TYM is pathetic (just as pathetic as SRK I guess) for blindly ignoring facts and defending the MK9 community, even though that community has nothing to back it up with. NOTHING.
You can say that you destroy Capcom players at MK9 and Injustice, but Capcom players have already won MK9 and Injustice tournaments, while no MK9 player ever switched to their games and did well.
You don't have to agree on that, but at least show some manners and don't call people out, who are stating the obvious. Just ignore them, if you can't handle the truth.
But you won't, since that's the way people are. People can't handle criticizm. Only few smart ones can and there are not many smart people on TYM / SRK / in the FGC.