I know what you mean, they did their job well according to all the other people who play/love the game, i couldnt take it seriously though, it was overhyped by the majority, i thought the fact that you couldnt fight and had to run was good too, but i didnt find it creepy and that bothered me the most about it, once you get past the "this game isnt scary" point, your just playing a stripped down puzzle game with bad lighting.
Silent hill was creepy, i wasnt 19 year old playing it though, so that definitely put something on there. I remember playing The Suffering on ps2 and that was generally a creepy game for me too.
More recently i played Dead Space 2, the first time round i did the entire game in the dark with surround sound headphones and i loved it, i played it through on the hardest difficulty setting, allowing yourself 3 save games for the entire playthrough, and when dying means you lose 4-5 hours of gameplay, you do panic a bit more often, i think the game outdid itself, but is still not the most intense horror experience, theres a hell of a lot of shoot em up elements in your face that you do get drawn away.
Swinging it back around then, what horror games did you enjoy, or find creepy or scary. Can you recommend anything for me to take a look into playing? (Dont say slender

)