IMO, the top 5 is basically set In stone (Kabal, kenshi, Sonya, cyrax, Freddy)
Its 6-10 is what most people are having mixed thoughts on. 6-10 definitely consists on Lao, smoke And kitana. The other two are really hard to determine.
I agree with the top 5.
That is something that has taken us over 2 years but that should not be anything to dispute anymore
top5 - kabal, kenshi, cyrax, sonya, freddy.
You are right saying that we have no idea for what to put in the 6-10 range. Even I am not too sure.
Some of my definites are the following.
top 6-10 - Kung lao, Kitana, Liu kang.
Potential characters to be in the last 2 spots for top 10 - Cage, skarlet?
I do not add jax because I believe the ones listed are better.
Smoke I do not believe to be top 10. Most people base this on his damage, but I am aware of how good the character is. I just feel there are 10 better characters then him.
Reptile, same as smoke. I know he is solid but there are better characters IMO.
If we were to use my list here. With the 6-10 being Lao, kitana, liu kang, cage and skarlet then we could easily bang out the 10-15.
my personal 10-15 are : jax,smoke,reptile, shang tsung and ermac.
with the characters i just listed, still not sure where to put sektor or raiden.
for the most part, this game is really balanced. the problem is really with just a few characters.