Menu
By:
Filters
What's new

I don't think it's too early for a really broad tier grouping...

RNLDRGN

RNLDRGN

RONALD ROGAN
Before you crucify me for having some fun and sparking conversation, a few notes:

1. This will be wrong. It's early and this will absolutely change and likely be inaccurate come tomorrow. You could move almost any character up/down. It's also my opinion--which means it's obviously not even close to perfect.

2. It's early. But it's not too early to say who is strong/weak IMO. So I'm keeping it broad and generic with just 3 tiers and no order within each. That's it. Notice I said "tier grouping"--semantics I know, but it matters a little.

3. I like labeling and grouping things so this is me enjoying myself. Not trying to shape anything significant or prove anyone wrong or right.

A Tier
Aquaman
Black Adam
Batman
Deadshot
Atrocitus

B Tier
Black Canary
Superman
Poison Ivy
Darkseid
Robin
Super Girl
Green Lantern
Harley
Capt Cold
Dr. Fate
Bane
Green Arrow
Brainiac
Flash
Firestorm
Cheetah
Catwoman
Gorilla Grodd
Cyborg


C Tier
Wonder Woman
Blue Beetle
Swamp Thing
Scarecrow
Joker


Am I way off? Tell me why.

EDIT: I have moved some characters after playing more matches and listening to some very welcomed feedback. See what I mean about not being perfect?
 
Last edited:
RNLDRGN

RNLDRGN

RONALD ROGAN
CrimsonShadow said:
Yeah, it's still too early for this.
Click to expand...
That was kind of the point...

I also think that with frame data in the game, tons of tournaments every week, Twitch, Youtube, and message boards that you don' t have to play a game for 12 months before ppl begin to figure out some of the meta and balance--esp with so many returning characters and a semi-public beta...

Yes high level will evolve in specific MUs, but anyone who has played the game for a couple of weeks can say "yeah, X character probably a bit weaker than Y character."
 
Cashual

Cashual

PSN: Cansuela
I know you'll get hate for this despite your gracious disclaimer, but I think for the current meta (infancy stage...game can and will change a lot) this isn't too bad. I think most people would agree with the groupings as of today, give or take a character here or there.

I think people will flame you (only partially rightfully so) because at this point some characters who appear weak are one potential piece of tech away from moving way up, and some stronger characters once properly labbed and countered could move significantly down.

Does anyone think Adam is actually that strong aside from his damage?

If his typical traited bnb did more like 400 instead of 500, I just don't think he'd be this dominating force. Maybe his divekick is especially strong due to the perceived strength of zoning and his ability to counter zone and get over it, so maybe he will still be top tier with a nerf to damage.

Intellectually I understand the relative futility to this exercise, but I still think it's fun, so fuck it.
 
RNLDRGN

RNLDRGN

RONALD ROGAN
Cashual said:
I know you'll get hate for this despite your gracious disclaimer, but I think for the current meta (infancy stage...game can and will change a lot) this isn't too bad. I think most people would agree with the groupings as of today, give or take a character here or there.

I think people will flame you (only partially rightfully so) because at this point some characters who appear weak are one potential piece of tech away from moving way up, and some stronger characters once properly labbed and countered could move significantly down.

Does anyone think Adam is actually that strong aside from his damage?

If his typical traited bnb did more like 400 instead of 500, I just don't think he'd be this dominating force. Maybe his divekick is especially strong due to the perceived strength of zoning and his ability to counter zone and get over it, so maybe he will still be top tier with a nerf to damage.

Intellectually I understand the relative futility to this exercise, but I still think it's fun, so fuck it.
Click to expand...
I think you get what I was going for pretty spot on. Every character on the roster is 1 buff, 1 piece of good tech, or one counter-measure away from moving anywhere.

But as of TODAY, I think this is pretty close.

And yeah totally agreed on BA. His toolset isn't broken, it's his ability to crap out 50%+ damage for 1 bar off a touch while half the cast can't do that much with 2 bars and/or super.
 
Cashual

Cashual

PSN: Cansuela
Also....is black canary really top tier? That surprises me, but I don't play her at all.

And, is supergirl quietly just bad? No one is playing her it seems and I know her damage is trash. Is her air dash, trait, b12 I think, and mb teleport good enough for he to be uppermid? Maybe not in a MU chart list uppermid but in terms of tools.
 
RNLDRGN

RNLDRGN

RONALD ROGAN
Cashual said:
Also....is black canary really top tier? That surprises me, but I don't play her at all.

And, is supergirl quietly just bad? No one is playing her it seems and I know her damage is trash. Is her air dash, trait, b12 I think, and mb teleport good enough for he to be uppermid? Maybe not in a MU chart list uppermid but in terms of tools.
Click to expand...
I think Super Girl is good. She has decent damage, good mobility, a free overhead crossup into B3 (ppl still aren't blocking this, myself included) and solid zoning w trait.

And I think Black Canary is top tier simply bc of how quickly she gets trait, her ability to re-stand, and her ridiculous damage. After Black Adam, she strikes me as one of the members of the cast who hits WAY too hard. Yes she relies heavily on trait, but once she gets in and mixes you up once your lifebar is pretty much gone. Cross up overhead leg-lock that leads into B3 for big damage is ridiculously good.
 
SHAOLIN

SHAOLIN

内部冲突
CrimsonShadow said:
Yeah, it's still too early for this.
Click to expand...
RNLDRGN said:
1. This will be wrong. It's early and this will absolutely change and likely be inaccurate come tomorrow. You could move almost any character up/down. It's also my opinion--which means it's obviously not even close to perfect.

2. It's early. But it's not too early to say who is strong/weak IMO. So I'm keeping it broad and generic with just 3 tiers and no order within each. That's it. Notice I said "tier grouping"--semantics I know, but it matters a little.

3. I like labeling and grouping things so this is me enjoying myself. Not trying to shape anything significant or prove anyone wrong or right.
Click to expand...
Yea I know its hard to read huh?
 
CrimsonShadow

CrimsonShadow

Administrator and Community Engineer
Administrator
RNLDRGN said:
I think Super Girl is good. She has decent damage, good mobility, a free overhead crossup into B3 (ppl still aren't blocking this, myself included) and solid zoning w trait.
Click to expand...
Not to call you out -- but I did play against you in Ranked with her yesterday, and it didn't seem like you knew what to do (or the counters for her options) at all :p

This is why I think it's semi-pointless to have these discussions at this point, until everyone knows more about the game.
 
D. R.

D. R.

Kombatant
Swamp Thing is the worst character in the game easily which sucks because he's the one character I actually enjoy playing. He has glaring issues that need to be addressed. I've found tech for multiple other characters but they never "stuck" as fun to play continuously. :-/

I can't wait til NRS over buff him. #undraintheswamp

Til then there's T7.
 
dribirut

dribirut

BLAK FELOW
Lol it's a damn forum. Of course it's not too early for this. It's just fun discussion. Do people not realize that tier lists are ever changing and apply to the current meta of the game... Jesus you guys must be lots of fun at parties.

Back to the list:
I think cyborg is actually really good. Top 3 zoning in the game. Very good plus frames. Can punish close to 40% now. Amazing f3 and b3. Good jump ins. I have him in my top ten easily.
 
RNLDRGN

RNLDRGN

RONALD ROGAN
CrimsonShadow said:
Not to call you out -- but I did play against you in Ranked with her yesterday, and it didn't seem like you knew what to do (or the counters for her options) at all :p

This is why I think it's semi-pointless to have these discussions at this point, until everyone knows more about the game.
Click to expand...
Maybe. Instead of coming in here to tout how you beat me (big congrats vs Swamp Thing btw), why don't you offer something constructive?

What was I not doing? What do you think makes her good/bad? Where would you put her?
 
RNLDRGN

RNLDRGN

RONALD ROGAN
D. R. said:
Swamp Thing is the worst character in the game easily which sucks because he's the one character I actually enjoy playing. He has glaring issues that need to be addressed. I've found tech for multiple other characters but they never "stuck" as fun to play continuously. :-/

I can't wait til NRS over buff him. #undraintheswamp

Til then there's T7.
Click to expand...
I don't know if he's the worst, but he's one of them. Once players know to duck his vines in neutral, begin to block his F23 footsie mixups (and punish the hella negative options accordingly), and jab or early jump in/crossup him out of his wakeup, he falls the fuck apart.

Which is fine. NRS will probably make him amazing in 9 months lol.
 
Crimson Panther

Crimson Panther

Noob
CrimsonShadow said:
Not to call you out -- but I did play against you in Ranked with her yesterday, and it didn't seem like you knew what to do (or the counters for her options) at all :p

This is why I think it's semi-pointless to have these discussions at this point, until everyone knows more about the game.
Click to expand...
You're playing Superbai too? Oh shit lol
 
CrimsonShadow

CrimsonShadow

Administrator and Community Engineer
Administrator
RNLDRGN said:
Maybe. Instead of coming in here to tout how you beat me (big congrats vs Swamp Thing btw), why don't you offer something constructive?

What was I not doing? What do you think makes her good/bad? Where would you put her?
Click to expand...
I'm not saying it to down or insult you at all -- I'm just saying I don't think it's as helpful to talk about how strong a character is until you know how to exploit their weaknesses.
 
Last edited:
RNLDRGN

RNLDRGN

RONALD ROGAN
CrimsonShadow said:
I'm not saying it to down you at all -- I'm just saying I don't think it's as helpful to talk about how strong a character is until you know how to exploit their weaknesses.
Click to expand...
There's probably a reason why the middle tier is so huge lol. Again, what do you think her strengths weaknesses are? Where would you put her?

I made this to start a conversation that is different from your typical "our character sucks" stuff within the character-specific forums. I'm curious as to everyone else's opinion--not just that they think I've voiced mine too soon. I admitted that at the very beginning of my post...
 
Last edited:
RNLDRGN

RNLDRGN

RONALD ROGAN
Reauxbot said:
Is say it's too soon as well but at the same time this would make a nice little thread to see what people think of each character.
No backlash or negativity should be required in anyone's post.
I'm quite fine with this thread.
Click to expand...
That's the point. I'm curious who thinks who is good/bad and why.
 
Dankster Morgan

Dankster Morgan

It is better this way
Idk, I don't know enough about the game yet to really comment, but I feel that the best characters are Black Adam, Batman, Aquaman, Superman, Atrocitus, and Deadshot. With Catwoman, Flash, Lantern, Harley, Robin, and Arrow not far behind. Fate, Supergirl, Darkseid, Bane, and Ivy are somewhere in the good but not amazing area. Swamp Thing and Brainiac are the worst to me, anyone not mentioned I have no clue.

Darkseid and Supergirl are extremely over rated by almost everyone btw, I think playing them online makes them way way better, no coincidence since they are tele characters.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.