What's new

How to beat Jade: Why people hate Jade and they are right

Status
Not open for further replies.

GLoRToR

Positive Poster!
So yeah people in general hate Jade. And they are right.
Jade HAS to be played frustratingly. It's by design, sadly.
They usually talk about D2 but mashing D2 is a result of a number of things.

I did some research and here's some reasons, consequences, and some understanding about why people hate her and how to work around it.

Getting the obvious out of the way: With Delia she's finally playing the MK11 Meta of "Oh-HO! Will I end my string in THIS or in THAT!!" which, if you think about it, is not at all different in concept from the MKX schmicksup games that people at the time hated so much. What makes MK11 even more frustrating at times is that you can walk back for free and then corner escape with armour on several stages, and while defending is severely disadvantageous in this game, having an invincible wakeup is still irritating to say the least. I mean, if your character has an actual mid invincible wakeup. Note: Jade does not. It hits mid, but you can just duck under it with a d3.
How To Beat Jade #1: Always d3 her on wakeup. She has to guess on wakeup against a meaty D3 into another D3, mid or Throw. True mixup. If she rolls past your D3, you can throw her. If she U3s, you'll punish. If she neutral jumps, D2.

I don't know if entirely different people made the characters but it kind of feels like that to me. Those who were here for the Entire Week they offered us to Beta Test a WHOLE TRIPLE A game (let that sink in for a moment. A week to Beta Test a game this huge.), remember that Scorpion, Baraka, Jade and Skarlet were the beta characters. The person who made Scorpion knew how to make hitboxes on moves. Scorpion cannot whiff. Ever. If you try to jump his meterburn teleport, if you try to D4 his F3, if you press on him you're fucked for a crushing blow or just get launched for 1 bar and a hefty chunk of your hp. People are in heavy denial about how good Scorpion is. There is Kabal who is basically Jade just better. More range, better hitboxes, better zoning, a fullscreen 20f launcher, he's a god.
Jade on the other hand, whiffs within her own hit ranges. All her Staff Normals are free-to-jumpable, death on block and have shitty frame data across the board. B2 is 10f at least so that's good, it can punish things many characters on the cast can't. But in the actual neutral (not that too many characters actually have to play the neutral, other than Jade herself) she can't stick out her buttons or she'll get blown up for it and their frame data is far too bad to actually use them pre-emptively.
How To Beat Jade #2: Learn at which tiny dots on the screen she actually hits and jump, duck, backdash her. She will whiff for 40+ frames and you'll get to punish.

Jade is annoying to fight against because even though she is forced to play "honestly" in a game that gives 0 fucks about neutral, most of her normals are trash. Save for B3 and D2, ad the fact that B2 can punish even some of the lesser pushbacks of the game. But then her damage is the worst in the entire cast.

How To Beat Jade #3
The above is the reason, then, why Jade's overall bad design makes you HAVE TO stick to what little good tools she has.
They are actually good, though, but boring, frustrating, poorly designed rushed nonsense showing that they care very little about Jade at NRS so they probably had an intern with directives do it.
D2 is 40+ frames of recover on whiff so just bait it out and blow her up.
Air Glaive gets jumped if used recklessly and you get anti-aired. It's not as good as people thought it was but she needs it badly because
D1 is t-rex as fuck. You get literally d1mash thrown if you try to play that game. You have to D1-parry on block and hope it isn't Cage or someone with a low starter.

Outdamage her, read when she's about to B3 and backash because she has to dial that string, it does not cancel on whiff and it's really bad on whiff.
Is she a good character? Yes.
Is she as good as some people think? Helnaw.
 
Last edited:

Shale101

Mortal
Out damaging her is a very effective strategy. Jumping is also very effective because god forbid you try to use her range with forward 21 or accidentally input the last 4 on back 3434 or a shadow kick on the end of back 343 while they are trying to jump. You will be dead. I'm an average player but I've played Jade since the beta. Seeing Sonic and Tekken play her in a tournament a few months ago solidified what I already knew....you can only really use her good tools. Air glaives, delia dance, back 343, back 2, down 3, and down 2. I was struck how in 3 matches I believe Sonic only attempted forward 2 like twice and both times unsuccessfully and Tekken didn't attempt it at all. 1 2 4 was not attempted much by either player. Back 1 the same. It feels like she is boxed in to play a certain way to be successful. Her damage IS very poor and its very frustrating when i feel like I've hit someone 10 different times and made some reads and then they hit me 3 times and I'm dead. I haven't played this game in awhile just because I find it tedious and not fun. I've been playing MKX Kitana mournful and it's just so much fun. The wakeup up options and Krushing Blows in MK11 are a nightmare. I'm ready for a new game! Hopefully a Marvel game. I also hope they learn from MK11 for MK12. I feel like this game failed in many ways.
 

Marlow

Champion
haha so funny......maybe you should try stand up ?
I've thought about it, but I already have a good job. Also I'm not a big fan of the hours and travel involved with stand up, and there's a good chance I'm not actually that funny. I'll probably just stick to making hilarious comments online.
 

GLoRToR

Positive Poster!
Yes, I'm sure one snarky response from Marlow is killing the site. It couldn't possibly be users posting nonstop negative posts and shitting on the game, the developer, and other users who enjoy the game.
No, it's the fact that instead of meaningful information people see one liners like that so they don't bother.
 

Shale101

Mortal
Yes, I'm sure one snarky response from Marlow is killing the site. It couldn't possibly be users posting nonstop negative posts and shitting on the game, the developer, and other users who enjoy the game.
A closed mouth doesn't get fed. People need to complain if they don't like something.....they are the buyer and have the right to. I'm sure NRS understands that half the people will always hate what you do and half will like it. That is the nature of the world. Constructive criticism and feedback is always needed. People are passionate about this franchise and allowed to complain.
 

Marlow

Champion
I always assumed TYM is dying simply because it's so much easier now to go and post stuff on YouTube, Twitter, Reddit, or Discord.

Either way, I think that there's a place for snarky comments alongside meaningful information. I don't think my comment takes anything away from the original post.
 
D

Deleted member 5032

Guest
A closed mouth doesn't get fed. People need to complain if they don't like something.....they are the buyer and have the right to. I'm sure NRS understands that half the people will always hate what you do and half will like it. That is the nature of the world. Constructive criticism and feedback is always needed. People are passionate about this franchise and allowed to complain.
There's a difference between complaining about valid criticisms and just constantly whining and shitting on the game and developers. What Marlow posted was just a funny observation about your statement. It wasn't even a troll post or toxic comment. Of all the things someone could complain about on this site, that comment is probably the silliest.
 

Shale101

Mortal
There's a difference between complaining about valid criticisms and just constantly whining and shitting on the game and developers. What Marlow posted was just a funny observation about your statement. It wasn't even a troll post or toxic comment. Of all the things someone could complain about on this site, that comment is probably the silliest.
Complaining/ valid criticism/ whining is subjective......you and I may have different definitions of those things. I didn't say anything about Marlow's statement other then " haha so funny......maybe you should try stand up ?". I have no problems with what he said.....I never complained about his comment...
 
D

Deleted member 5032

Guest
Complaining/ valid criticism/ whining is subjective......you and I may have different definitions of those things. I didn't say anything about Marlow's statement other then " haha so funny......maybe you should try stand up ?". I have no problems with what he said.....I never complained about his comment...
You didn't, but Glortor did, and what's what got us on this conversation. I'm not saying you're whining, you're good.
 

Dogeofthesea

Apprentice
Her B343 string is punishable on hit by wake up U2 if the B3 catches jumping, then the rest whiffs. It doesn't matter if you press B3434 or B343 dance or whatever, wake up U2 will punish it every time.
Her B3434 plus frame is usable now because she has Delia dance, but it has random push back vs different characters, especially in the corner. Want to use B3 after you are +5 from B3434? Too bad it has random push back, B3 whiffs and you can be punished.
Her d4 is terrible. After d4 on hit you're +14, but if you hit it at max range you can't do anything other than dash forward d4, because the hit animation makes everyone walk out of range of all of your normals. Her d1 is EXTREMELY short
For some reasons Glow has tons of recovery frames. Why Liu Kang can literally cancel his strings into the damage buff with almost 0 recovery and stays safe right in your face, but Jade's Glow can be punished fullscreen/on reaction by teleporters and Kabal is beyond me.
All of her knockdown moves have terrible hit advantage. Hitting people with shadow kick or mb version, what's next? Dash up block because there's nothing you can do after than. Hitting B3434 sometimes feel worse than B3434 on block, because I always got blown up by Liu or Cetrion wakeup buttons. And her F4 sends people fullscreen for some reasons?
And finally, I hate play Mortal Kombat without combos. I have to switch to Jade because j3 and Cetrion in this game are way too broken, but spamming B343 DF2 a million times a day only makes me hate Jade's design and the game itself even more.
I'm glad that I only spent money on the base game on a Steam sales. Games like MK11 don't deserve my full support
 

Juxtapose

Master
I always assumed TYM is dying simply because it's so much easier now to go and post stuff on YouTube, Twitter, Reddit, or Discord.
Forums are indeed, and in my opinion sadly, dying. The current generation of gamers prefer "live" services, i.e. Discord and Twitch, over older style forums, and that's the direction everything is going. Bethesda just closed it's own forums in favour of Discord and Reddit. Blizzard Entertainment quietly encourages StarCraft II players to Reddit as opposed to their official forums, Mortal Kombat 11, to my knowledge, has never even had official forums to my knowledge.

As someone who's moderated forums and game communities before, I can also say that negativity generally turns most folk away from a board. I don't mean jokes (unless they're really offensive/tasteless) or constructive criticism, but constant whining and heavy aggressive nature and complaints will keep lurkers from actually participating in a forum community, and generally push all but trolls and keyboard warriors away.

Keeping a community lite-hearted but constructive is usually the best way to keep it going, in my experience.
 

GLoRToR

Positive Poster!
You didn't, but Glortor did, and what's what got us on this conversation. I'm not saying you're whining, you're good.
I didn't either, I called out a completely useless post that did nothing for the discussion. To which you responded negatively yourself. For a board admin you really know how to derail a post.
 
D

Deleted member 5032

Guest
I didn't either, I called out a completely useless post that did nothing for the discussion. To which you responded negatively yourself. For a board admin you really know how to derail a post.
What? You say you didn't and did in literally the same sentence. Your "calling out" of the post is what I was referring to.
No, it's the fact that instead of meaningful information people see one liners like that so they don't bother.
As far as negativity is concerned, I see nothing wrong with using mild sarcasm to point out how you are actively hurting the site with your posts, and the hypocrisy of trying to blame such damage on Marlow. Based on your post history, I honestly think you need to drop MK11 for the sake of your mental health.
 

GLoRToR

Positive Poster!
What? You say you didn't and did in literally the same sentence. Your "calling out" of the post is what I was referring to.
Didn't whine, I was trying to be constructive, telling people how to beat Jade, what her struggles are and even said two characters who are better than her and easily counter her. I don't understand what you problem is with me or why you think I'm hurting the site, but if that's the case I don't need to be here.

I'm sorry for hurting the site. Take care, hope you'll manage to revive it, it used to be great.
 
D

Deleted member 5032

Guest
Didn't whine, I was trying to be constructive, telling people how to beat Jade, what her struggles are and even said two characters who are better than her and easily counter her. I don't understand what you problem is with me or why you think I'm hurting the site, but if that's the case I don't need to be here.

I'm sorry for hurting the site. Take care, hope you'll manage to revive it, it used to be great.
I never said you were whining in this thread, I just said you complained about Marlow's post. My problem is with the excessive amount of negativity you bring to the site. You don't like MK11, great, we get it. But this is a fan site. We like the game, for the most part, and it gets tiring logging in every day to see a new status or thread from Glortor complaining about the same things that have been around since release. If you hate the game then yes, please go and you and TYM will be much happier. But if you actually want to ask legit questions and learn how to play the game better and counter the things that are giving you problems, then I welcome you to continue to enjoy TYM.
 

theotherguy

Kombatant
1st post was good
2nd post was somewhat insightful
3rd post was funny
4th post missed the funny part of #3
5th post brought the funny back
6th post... well... that's when it all turned to shit...

I think this thread needs a good cleanup, at least move the off-topic talk to another thread.
 

Arqwart

D'Vorah for KP2 copium
Gunna agree to your first point in her design being limited and sorta disagree with your conclusion as to her not being as good as people say (aka top 10 or just outside it depending on whom was asked). I think a key differentiator is that you are 100% correct that Jade isn't as good as people say... outside of pro play. Patience, reads, reactions, consistency -- these are things that pro players tend to have an abundance of. They lab like maniacs because they're competitors. The rest of us playing casually? Ya, no. Aint no abundance of anything here except yolo risks. With Jade only having a few good tools, she becomes a character where top notch reactions, reads, and conditioning are key because she must keep the match pace in line where her tools work. Casual players aren't going to regularly make that happen, if ever. I'd drop Jade from the tail end of top 10 to upper mid tier at most for casual play.

Overall, I know you and I at MK11's release and the following year or so before you left TYM for a bit agreed a lot on Jade's design being.. disappointing to say the very least. Really all that's notably changed since then is the poke patch, addition of armor breakers, and the introduction of customs letting Jade abuse the hell out of Delia's and Air Rang together. However, I feel you're really underselling just how good those two tools are when combined with her other good tools: B3 string, D2, D4, D3 low profiling air attacks, 1 being a pretty good anti-air, Glow shutting down a lot of options including common pressure tools like shadow slide, 21/212 being great staggers, her jump kick being silly (but that's just MK11), B2, Glow Kick being her armor breaker, sweep, and throws.

Ya, she can get blown up for tossing out anything resembling footsie attempts (other than D4) against people knowing to duck or back up. That's less of a Jade issue and more of a player issue in my mind, though. If that is happening to a Jade player over and over, that shows a lack of adaptation by the player, not an inherent limitation of the character. Tossing out B2, one of THE most hitconfirmable single normals in the entire game alongside having no hurtbox due to weapon range, SHOULD be risky. Random D2s SHOULD be death on whiff. Constantly jumping to mash air rangs SHOULD be read, adapted to, and punished by the opponent. Again, seems more of a player issue than a character issue for regularly getting blown up sticking out buttons. Footsie poke tools are for halting opponents you know are regularly acting as aggressors, not for throwing out willy nilly.

Are her active frames shit?
Is her D1 trash?
Is she death on whiff almost always?
Is she death on block for many tools?
Is her damage subpar as hell?
Is her main mid string a dial-in, leaving her defenseless if she commits in bad moments?
Is half her toolkit either outclassed by other tools so they're useless or so bad it's actively a BAD idea to use them?

Yes to all of the above. But again, it's on the player to avoid her garbage tools entirely and utilize her good tools appropriately. When a player pulls that off (such as SonicFox), Jade is amazing and deserving her high tier placement.
 

GLoRToR

Positive Poster!
I never said you were whining in this thread, I just said you complained about Marlow's post. My problem is with the excessive amount of negativity you bring to the site. You don't like MK11, great, we get it. But this is a fan site. We like the game, for the most part, and it gets tiring logging in every day to see a new status or thread from Glortor complaining about the same things that have been around since release. If you hate the game then yes, please go and you and TYM will be much happier. But if you actually want to ask legit questions and learn how to play the game better and counter the things that are giving you problems, then I welcome you to continue to enjoy TYM.
And my problem is with thread derailing, shitposting, and all the problems this board has always had.
You're perfectly fine with that, but you single me out for some reason, in a constructive thread I started.
SRK, while it lasted, had serious repercussions for the behaviour you're supporting in this thread, including how you public witchhunt me with your buddies.
It's a perfectly valid thing to ask of people to not shitpost.
I will always speak up about things I dislike. If that makes me unwelcome here then it's fine, it's quite apparent that this board is more about the "lmao glortor" people than the people who as you claim, want to get better at the game. That's why all the top players are gone by now.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.