A) every top player that i've talked to has either agreed 100% or had 1-2 swaps that only changed a character up/down a tier
B) this tier list hasn't been posted here before
C) What makes you think you know better than top players?
D) explain whats wrong with it
A) List "Top" players that have agreed.
B) A list VERY similar with he same style HAS been posted on TYM just a few days ago, I just can't find the thread atm I swear.
C) I NEVER stated I knew more. You put words in my mouth. I simply stated there were allot of things wrong with it. People are finding new tech every day it seems, so IMO tier lists are garbage. To top it off, the patch we will get in the next month or so will probably change everything.
D) Ask your "TOP" players which ones they moved around, that should tell you there is conflict within the list. And, for the record I have seen some pretty awesome Shazam players, and I don't think he's that bad of a character, but that's my op.
Making a tier list is a joke to the highest degree IMO! The skill a PLAYER puts into it is what makes a character good or bad. Sure there are things about the character design that can hinder or make them OP, but it's whether or not a player knows how to abuse or avoid those abilities with their chosen character is the key, at least this is what I see. In the current state of IGAU I've seen people take a character that was thought of as lacking in ability to win via match-ups like Grundy and seen people like Tyrant do amazing things with him to win tournaments.
I think we need to hold off on "Tier Lists" until NRS announces there will be NO MORE changes to the game. Then like MK9 we can put together an accurate list.