GamerBlake90
Blue Blurs for Life!
I don't play in tournaments so I regularly change characters. Actually it goes deeper than that. I don't play in tournaments because I switch characters often. Changing play-styles, characters and trying out new stuff is more fun to me than winning. I don't need to win as long as I can have good, interesting and somewhat close matches. However I'd rather drop the game and do something else than commit to a single character or even two.
Some people are just wired that way. Maybe you are one of us and if you are then that is kind of bad news for you if you want to do good in tournaments because you either switch characters often (here called a "character crisis") and therefore don't play at your peak potential or you are sticking to maybe two characters yet don't have as much fun as you could have. Bad luck. There is literally nothing you can do about that choice unless you dedicate your entire life to this game.
No, that isn't the case at all. If it had to come to me just staying with one or two characters, I can do that. Back when I started out as a fighting game player, I stuck with one character for like four months or so, before I began expanding across the roster.
As Cossner correctly explained, there are benefits to doing that. A good answer to overcoming a bad match-up, whether it be a personal one for you or a match-up your character really is disadvantaged in, is understanding how that particular character works. You wouldn't have to "main" him, though...just develop a core understanding of his/her mechanics so you'll be better-prepared for when you fight that character again.
I admit, part of what pushed me to go nuts in learning the roster was all the bullshit hate Sonya got as a character in MK9 (safe abusable armored launchers that cost meter, safe Military Stance offense, long-ass d4, 50%+ meterless damage, etc.)...in other words, the typical top-tier hatred that causes some to think, "If he wasn't using any of that bullshit in the game, he wouldn't be doing as well." Even efforts to help people learn the Sonya match-up were never worthwhile as they preferred to just shake their head and laugh. So I learned many characters to get those complaints off my back. And I'm far from the only one to deal with something like this.
Not my fault if the characters I pick at first sight turn out to be godlike later in the game...it's not like I planned to just whore out top-tiers. They sort of fall right into my lap.
Also, to everyone else posting, I would like to express that this thread wasn't opened with the intention of helping one person. I know there's more than one player who struggle when faced with a character crisis, as some posts in here already reflect, so I wanted to start a discussion that would help such players to figure out what they wanna do. A way to assist the community, in other words. Nevertheless, I appreciate all the answers this thread is getting and I look forward to reading more of them.