Who were the Top 5 best MK9 Players?

[james1926]

On a side note, quality of tournaments wins > quantity of tournaments wins. Nobody calls Tottenham a better team for winning the Carling Cup more times than Chelsea has won the Champions League. And nobody calls Holland a better team than Spain for reaching the World Cup final more times than Spain have won it.

Smarrgasm will probably be the only person who gets that analogy but oh well, I don't know shit about the NFL. #SawkerAnalogies

Actually there are many who call Holland a better team than Spain for reaching the World Cup final more times than Spain have won it. Holland was in three WC finals and they lost all three. Spain was in only 1 and they won it. Now, is just an opinion on which team is better in overall football history, as is just an opinion on who is the best MK player. (though I think its such a bad comparison (football and MK lol))

 

[Flagg]

The thread is not about who were the best five at Evo2k13, but all-time best five MK players.

In that case I would say REO, PL, F0xy, 16 Bit and one of the Terry Bro's.

 

[1man3letters]

inpo

Zoidberg747
TheTetraSpirit
SomeCubanGuy
FlipinFlava
1man3letters

all the rest were weak lil bitches

 

[ryublaze]

Can I be on the kid list? I'm 19 and Error is 18 i think...

 

[Error]

Can I be on the kid list? I'm 19 and Error is 18 i think...

Fool, I'm older than you by a few days.

 

[BlaqandMild15]

If this were to happen, it would be funny as hell if the aliens won only using low-mid tier characters.

 

[G4S Claude VonStroke]

Shouldn't we be going by overall tournament resumes in top 8 and top 3 placings? And of course overall wins? What else can we go by? If you do that then...

REO
PL
CD Jr
Maxter
Pig or DJT

And i'm completely being as unbiased as possible for this. IF you look at the overall MK9 resumes, it would be hard to argue this list.

 

[Groove Heaven]

REO
Pig
PL
Jr.
Dizzy

I know Dizzy didn't win a ton of shit but his fundamentals and knowledge of the game always impressed me a lot.

 

[SaJa]

Umm no? Give me one good reason why you think gross is top 5?

EDIT: Didn't realize that you quoted my kid list. I don't think gross is young enough

I though he was that young. :/ My bad.

 

[CURBOLICOUS]

Shouldn't we be going by overall tournament resumes in top 8 and top 3 placings? And of course overall wins? What else can we go by? If you do that then...

REO
PL
CD Jr
Maxter
Pig or DJT

And i'm completely being as unbiased as possible for this. IF you look at the overall MK9 resumes, it would be hard to argue this list.

If you wanna go by tourney results use the MKI rankings that crimson dude made

 

[G4S Claude VonStroke]

If you wanna go by tourney results use the MKI rankings that crimson dude made

I don't believe they were from the beginning of MK9. Unless i'm mistaken.

 

[G4S Claude VonStroke]

The question is who were the best, meaning in the entire life span of the game. Not who is the best right now... If that's the case I stand by my list 100 percent.

 

[Simon Wayne]

This list is the only correct list

PL
DJT
REO
CDJR
PIG

 

[Nephrite]

This list is the only correct list

PL
DJT
REO
CDJR
PIG

Hehe, your list is same as mine.

I was having doubts between Pig & Detroit (both had good results in majors and MLGs), but in the end I went with Pig 'cause he placed 3rd at Evo vs Detroit's 7th. I know Detroit also has two 9th place finishes, but a bronze medal is a bronze medal...

Another one on my mind was Maxter because he had numerous high placings at majors, but since he never broke into Evo Top8 I decided to choose between Pig and Detroit for the final spot.