Of course people get opened up. But sonic got hit with it in a 50/50 scenario and not as a whiff punisher. When people say it's reactable it should mean that in a 50/50 scenario OH or low case, the overhead should be blocked every single time. But it doesnt. You cannot compare f4 of Erron Black as it is a mixup by itself as its startup is similar to Slide lul.
As for your statement, the reason people get opened up could be due to:
- pressing buttons
- input errors
- trying to jump
But this is not the case in the scenario I'm referring to. This is Sub-Zero tried and true mixup against Sonic Fox, who gets head by the overhead in a guessing situation. You gotta HOLD this fact, you cant just keep brushing it aside by claiming I have no knowledge of FG's. These personal attacks just indicates you have run out of stuff to say lul
I literally just proved to you he was used in top 8. How are we supposed to have a discussion when you say stupid stuff like it "doesnt mean a sh***". I have to acknowledge Sonic's videos. I cant just say "oh, for no apparent reason imma just say it's irrelevant". Support your claims with
evidence and less emotions
Yes, he has shown he can do it in a training room with nothing else to worry about. He has also shown, that he cannot apply this in real matches, thus making the notion that it's reactable at least partly false. It is a fuzzy-able mixup if done at the first possible frame, but it's not applicably reactable.
Nobody is calling for nerfs, sigh. You're just downplaying how good Sub is a high level. Scar was beat by a Sub player at CEO - and listen, Scar is one of the most consistent NRS players and fundamentally strong players as well. He's Sonic's training partner ffs and has beat him in grand finals before. This guy's reactions is no joke. If he falls to Sub-Zero it means the character is PRETTY damn solid.