For the following, I assume each follow-up uses equal meter and performs an equal number of non-guaranteed resets. What I mean by "non-guaranteed resets" is the sweep ender knockdown into oki or the trait reset itself. For example, the f22 xx trait; dbf1 MB, b3, j3, 112 xx db2 combo is a 1 bar, 1 reset possibility for the trait follow-up, whereas f22; dbf1 MB, b3, j2, j2, d3; dbf1 is a 1 bar, 1 reset possibility for the guaranteed grab follow-up. The follow-ups I have considered for the trait mix-up are dbf1 (MB), 22 xx dbf1 (MB), f12 xx dbf1 (MB), db1 (MB), b3 MB, f3 MB, and b2 xx dbf1 (MB) and the follow-ups I have considered for the d3 knockdown are dbf1 (MB), 22 xx dbf1 (MB), b3 MB, f3 MB. I feel these options are sufficient for accurate comparison. Also, simply averaging the damage values from each follow-up is not an entirely fair comparison since some are more likely to be used and/or more useful than others, but in the absence of an absolute way to weigh their values, I'm simply going to consider them all equal in weight (the damage values are rather uniform anyway). I'm also using the combos that I would use in a real match if I had to use the designated starter, ender, and amount of meter/resets, so a small amount of discrepancy may be present there, but it shouldn't matter much.
1 bar, 1 non-guaranteed reset
f22; dbf1 MB, b3, j2, j2, d3; dbf1 - 47%
f22; dbf1 MB, b3, j2, j2, d3; 22 xx dbf1 - 50%
AVERAGE: 48.5%
f22 xx trait; dbf1 MB, b3, j3, 112 xx bf2 - 54%
f22 xx trait; 22 xx dbf1 MB, b3, j3, 12 xx dbf1 - 46%
f22 xx trait; db1 MB, f223 xx dbf1 - 43%
f22 xx trait; b2 xx dbf1 MB, b3, j3, 12 xx dbf1 - 53%
f22 xx trait; f12 xx dbf1 MB, b3, j3, 12 xx dbf1 - 50%
f22 xx trait; b3 MB, j3, j2, 112 xx bf2 - 55%
f22 xx trait; f3 MB, j3, 112 xx dbf1 - 52%
AVERAGE: 50.4%
trait variation deals about 2% more damage and leaves you with about 3-5 seconds of trait
2 bars, 1 non-guaranteed reset
f22; dbf1 MB, b3, j2, j2, d3; dbf1 MB, b3, j3, f223 xx dbf1 - 72%
f22; dbf1 MB, b3, j2, j2, d3; 22 xx dbf1 MB, b3, j2, f223 xx dbf1 - 67%
f22; dbf1 MB, b3, j2, j2, d3; b3 MB, j3, j2, 112 xx bf2 - 70%
f22; dbf1 MB, b3, j2, j2, d3; f3 MB, j3, 112 xx bf2 - 66%
AVERAGE: 68.8%
f22 xx trait; dbf1 MB, b3, j3, f2 xx db1 MB, 12 xx dbf1 - 61%
f22 xx trait; 22 xx dbf1 MB, b3, j3, f1 xx db1 MB, 12 xx dbf1 - 52%
f22 xx trait; db1 MB, 12 xx dbf1 MB, j3, 12 xx dbf1 - 63%
f22 xx trait; b2 xx dbf1 MB, b3, j3, f1 xx db1 MB, 12 xx dbf1 - 59%
f22 xx trait; f12 xx dbf1 MB, b3, j3, f1 xx db1 MB, 12 xx dbf1 - 57%
f22 xx trait; b3 MB, j3, j2, 1 xx db1 MB, 12 xx dbf1 - 62%
f22 xx trait; f3 MB, j3, 1 xx db1 MB, 12 xx dbf1 - 60%
AVERAGE: 59.1%
trait variation deals about 10% less damage and leaves you with about 2-4 seconds of trait
2 bars, 2 non-guaranteed resets
f22; dbf1 MB, b3, j2, j2, d3; dbf1 MB, b3, j2, j2, d3; dbf1 - 76%
f22; dbf1 MB, b3, j2, j2, d3; dbf1 MB, b3, j2, j2, d3; 22 xx dbf1 - 79%
f22; dbf1 MB, b3, j2, j2, d3; 22 xx dbf1 MB, b3, j3, d3; dbf1 - 74%
f22; dbf1 MB, b3, j2, j2, d3; 22 xx dbf1 MB, b3, j3, d3; 22 xx dbf1 - 77%
f22; dbf1 MB, b3, j2, j2, d3; b3 MB, j3, j2, d3; dbf1 - 75%
f22; dbf1 MB, b3, j2, j2, d3; b3 MB, j3, j2, d3; 22 xx dbf1 - 78%
f22; dbf1 MB, b3, j2, j2, d3; f3 MB, j3, d3; dbf1 - 71%
f22; dbf1 MB, b3, j2, j2, d3; f3 MB, j3, d3; dbf1 - 74%
AVERAGE: 75.5%
f22 xx trait; dbf1 MB, b3, j3, d3; dbf1 MB, b3, j3, 112 xx bf2 - 88%
f22 xx trait; dbf1 MB, b3, j3, d3; 22 xx dbf1 MB, b3, j3, 12 xx dbf1 - 80%
f22 xx trait; dbf1 MB, b3, j3, d3; b3 MB, j3, j2, 112 xx bf2 - 89%
f22 xx trait; dbf1 MB, b3, j3, d3; f3 MB, j3, 112 xx bf2 - 86%
f22 xx trait; 22 xx dbf1 MB, b3, j3, d3; dbf1 MB, b3, j3, 112 xx bf2 - 86%
f22 xx trait; 22 xx dbf1 MB, b3, j3, d3; 22 xx dbf1 MB, b3, j3, 12 xx dbf1 - 78%
f22 xx trait; 22 xx dbf1 MB, b3, j3, d3; b3 MB, j3, j2, 112 xx bf2 - 87%
f22 xx trait; 22 xx dbf1 MB, b3, j3, d3; f3 MB, j3, 112 xx bf2 - 84%
f22 xx trait; db1 MB, d3; dbf1 MB, b3, j3, 112 xx bf2 - 74%
f22 xx trait; db1 MB, d3; 22 xx dbf1 MB, b3, j3, 12 xx dbf1 - 64%
f22 xx trait; db1 MB, d3; b3 MB, j3, j2, 112 xx bf2 - 75%
f22 xx trait; db1 MB, d3; f3 MB, j3, 112 xx bf2 - 72%
f22 xx trait; b2 xx dbf1 MB, b3, j3, d3; dbf1 MB, b3, j3, 112 xx bf2 - 90%
f22 xx trait; b2 xx dbf1 MB, b3, j3, d3; 22 xx dbf1 MB, b3, j3, 12 xx dbf1 - 84%
f22 xx trait; b2 xx dbf1 MB, b3, j3, d3; b3 MB, j3, j2, 112 xx bf2 - 93%
f22 xx trait; b2 xx dbf1 MB, b3, j3, d3; f3 MB, j3, 112 xx bf2 - 90%
f22 xx trait; f12 xx dbf1 MB, b3, j3, d3; dbf1 MB, b3, j3, 112 xx bf2 - 87%
f22 xx trait; f12 xx dbf1 MB, b3, j3, d3; 22 xx dbf1 MB, b3, j3, 12 xx dbf1 - 81%
f22 xx trait; f12 xx dbf1 MB, b3, j3, d3; b3 MB, j3, j2, 112 xx bf2 - 90%
f22 xx trait; f12 xx dbf1 MB, b3, j3, d3; f3 MB, j3, 112 xx bf2 - 87%
f22 xx trait; b3 MB, j3, j2, d3; dbf1 MB, b3, j3, 112 xx bf2 - 87%
f22 xx trait; b3 MB, j3, j2, d3; 22 xx dbf1 MB, b3, j3, 12 xx dbf1 - 81%
f22 xx trait; b3 MB, j3, j2, d3; b3 MB, j3, j2, 112 xx bf2 - 90%
f22 xx trait; b3 MB, j3, j2, d3; f3 MB, j3, 112 xx bf2 - 87%
f22 xx trait; f3 MB, j3, d3; dbf1 MB, b3, j3, 112 xx bf2 - 83%
f22 xx trait; f3 MB, j3, d3; 22 xx dbf1 MB, b3, j3, 12 xx dbf1 - 77%
f22 xx trait; f3 MB, j3, d3; b3 MB, j3, j2, 112 xx bf2 - 86%
f22 xx trait; f3 MB, j3, d3; f3 MB, j3, 112 xx bf2 - 83%
AVERAGE: 83.5%
trait variation deals about 8% more damage and leaves you with no trait