What characters punish her? Hawk girl and batman. Green lantern not no more from me. She is A+ material. I'f not. Then I will break it down for u on Friday
What ... so ... um ... how the hell do I even reply to what you said?
Alright, first, why Hawk Girl over Aquaman? His trait and his footsies pretty much shuts CW usual strategy down.
Now, let me break it down for ya right now: it's true she has some very potent tools for high-level play, such as:
-112: 6f high; safe on block against most things and hit-confirmable into full combo
-f112: 16f advancing overhead; safe on block against most things and hit-confirmable into full combo
-b12d3: 14f low; safe on block against most things and hit-confirmable into full combo
-b3: 23f advancing mid, safe on block, hit-confirmable into full combo, and able to MB for armor
-Cat Dash: 17f half-screen advancing mid, punishable on block, but can be MB for armor, full-screen, and various setups
-Cat Scratch: 17f mid, safe on block, and fully invincible on wakeup
-Evade: 3f dodge that builds up trait if successful
But her tools are severely outclassed by other characters' tools, such as Batman's zoning and frametraps or Aquaman's footsies and trait. Now, if the metagame was more patient a la old school Street Fighter 2, then I could see her being top tier as she can punish any mistake except for a jump-in with good damage.