This is the problem, it doesnt suck at all (I MAIN NW IM NOT TROLLING SO DONT EVEN TRY) what you really mean is you want more OPTIONS (which i have been saying since day one).
Understand that NW is a very dry and he similar to baraka with movement and fundamentals so the core will never change but let me address your points.
1.) thats 18% damage for one string, you are out of your mind especially for someone who has the tools for ALL areas
2.) once again you want 25% damage (1/4th of health) for a string, and i dont get hjow you guys say you want more depth yet all your suggestion limit it.
3.) Command grab is command grab it doesnt need to be completely broken (unless you can show this is something other character have across the board ill have no issue then)
4.)31 tick would be way too broken considering how good the recovery is on it
Ill post my ideas in a second
I also main NW, Shaman and Matoka Warrior shit on this variation IMO.
1: This gives him a punishment dynamic come on bruh lol. Tools that become useless after the KB is spent are wack.
2: Yes I do. This normal is stubby af, it'd just be a block punish and it would work against few things. Chill out.
3: It's a high command grab which can be hella OS'd against opposed to the mid ones. I LIKE having mid or high command throws, but the high ones need to be buffer than the mid ones to compensate IMO.
4: 31 tick would have synergy. It'd be 31~throw or 312 for the KB.