What's new

Do you WANT a redo?

Read the reasons for and against then decide if this tournament needs to be redone

  • Yes, redo it

    Votes: 20 37.7%
  • No, dont redo it

    Votes: 33 62.3%

  • Total voters
    53

DJ L Toro

Champion
then what you said merits neither a read through or a response. But just to be gracious to a guest of my thread, my argument WAS (and that's the important part) that everyone had a chance to beat REO, they just lost. Sure, it's against the rules for him to be in the tournament, but he still played the same MK game everyone else was playing. But anyway, we're pretty far past that already. before Reno_Racks and Son of Timett made an extremely generous offer to pay out of pocket for a new tournament (not a redo, but i can see why more people have been voting yes on here) the vote was 75% no for a redo.
 

rev0lver

Come On Die Young
then what you said merits neither a read through or a response. But just to be gracious to a guest of my thread, my argument WAS (and that's the important part) that everyone had a chance to beat REO, they just lost. Sure, it's against the rules for him to be in the tournament, but he still played the same MK game everyone else was playing. But anyway, we're pretty far past that already. before Reno_Racks and Son of Timett made an extremely generous offer to pay out of pocket for a new tournament (not a redo, but i can see why more people have been voting yes on here) the vote was 75% no for a redo.
75% of the community lacks intelligence. All I wanted to do is point out fraudulence.
 

Grumptronix

Fuck off, I'm not grumpy
75% of the community lacks intelligence. All I wanted to do is point out fraudulence.
75% is a gross understatement, and you are a clear example of that. And your point regarding "fraudulence" is the redundant opinion I was referring to. Don't hurt yourself on your way out.
 

DJ L Toro

Champion
75% is a gross understatement, and you are a clear example of that. And your point regarding "fraudulence" is the redundant opinion I was referring to. Don't hurt yourself on your way out.
come on, dont be rude, rev0lver is a cool dude, he just disagrees with what i'm saying. That's fine. I was just trying to see what THOSE AFFECTED by this incident wanted instead of just doing something because people are salty about reo ruining their work (pig/cpt). revolver you gotta understand that all the salt is retrospective because while the tourny was going everyone had a good time. just suddently when people find out 2nd place was reo that changes things. but i dont think it should because 1) people had fun, 2) someone that actually paid entry won. but that's just MY OPIONION (though it seems to be shared with a large portion of the community. if you think most of the community is dumb then leave)
 

rev0lver

Come On Die Young
come on, dont be rude, rev0lver is a cool dude, he just disagrees with what i'm saying. That's fine. I was just trying to see what THOSE AFFECTED by this incident wanted instead of just doing something because people are salty about reo ruining their work (pig/cpt). revolver you gotta understand that all the salt is retrospective because while the tourny was going everyone had a good time. just suddently when people find out 2nd place was reo that changes things. but i dont think it should because 1) people had fun, 2) someone that actually paid entry won. but that's just MY OPIONION (though it seems to be shared with a large portion of the community. if you think most of the community is dumb then leave)
Tell him to be rude because I want to play with him.

I scanned over the rest of the thread and my point is that whether it was Madzin or my best friend, the winner of this tournament would be fraudulent because of an ineligible competitor, whether or not someone puts up a new pot.
 

DJ L Toro

Champion
........still ironing out

Almost dOne

The Progress and solutions IMO have been the best available solutions

No sense in sharing till all is solidified
thanks, for the record when i mentioned you in the responce to revolver that was just about the perception of why a redo was being done. i think you actually mean the best for the community and am very appreciative
 

DJ L Toro

Champion
Tell him to be rude because I want to play with him.

I scanned over the rest of the thread and my point is that whether it was Madzin or my best friend, the winner of this tournament would be fraudulent because of an ineligible competitor, whether or not someone puts up a new pot.
oh i thought you meant like the argument was fraudulent. i was like man i know people say that in the hood (i'm originally from chicago), but technically that's incorrect. nevermind your usage is fine, lol
 

sunky21

Noob
This is easy logic! I honestly give props to MADZIN for winnnig i lost to him on losers as well. He deserved the win. NOW!! the tournament clearly states that winnings MUST be used to go to MLG and this guy isnt even coming so he shudnt have even entered on the first place as easy as that! Secondly, there needs to be a redo, why? because even tho madzin took it and not REO one match changes the outcome of the whole tournament! either someone going into losers when they coudve won on winners. Anything could change the outcome! I honestly dont care about the money i paid to entered i did it for the fun of it and the chance to play with some cool friends! This tourney was for some of us online players to have a chance at MLG and the two ppl in grand finals shudnteven have been there. REO couldnt play and Madzin is not coming so the what was the point of the tourney. There needs to be a redo and an actual online player whos willing to go to MLG shoudld take it! I would be happy if someone like blake, bwizz, krayzie or lulz i mean just anyone.

And krayzie thanks btw lol that wouldve been nice of you hehe i actually was thinking of sponsoring someone from socal if i wudve won too.

ALso, someone pitching in the $250 i think is just amazing, but he shouldnt even have to do that. the ppl responsible for what happened has to. but thats how u can tell we have immature kids in this community who dont take responsability for their actions.
 

DJ L Toro

Champion
This is easy logic! I honestly give props to MADZIN for winnnig i lost to him on losers as well. He deserved the win. NOW!! the tournament clearly states that winnings MUST be used to go to MLG and this guy isnt even coming so he shudnt have even entered on the first place as easy as that! Secondly, there needs to be a redo, why? because even tho madzin took it and not REO one match changes the outcome of the whole tournament! either someone going into losers when they coudve won on winners. Anything could change the outcome! I honestly dont care about the money i paid to entered i did it for the fun of it and the chance to play with some cool friends! This tourney was for some of us online players to have a chance at MLG and the two ppl in grand finals shudnteven have been there. REO couldnt play and Madzin is not coming so the what was the point of the tourney. There needs to be a redo and an actual online player whos willing to go to MLG shoudld take it! I would be happy if someone like blake, bwizz, krayzie or lulz i mean just anyone.

And krayzie thanks btw lol that wouldve been nice of you hehe i actually was thinking of sponsoring someone from socal if i wudve won too.

ALso, someone pitching in the $250 i think is just amazing, but he shouldnt even have to do that. the ppl responsible for what happened has to. but thats how u can tell we have immature kids in this community who dont take responsability for their actions.
What's the point and not allowed are two different things. Madzin entered thinking he was ALLOWED to play, even if him winning would be "pointless." i think he was under the same impression as me that the original rules said you could designate someone to go in your place if you couldnt make it (because even some american guys cant make it even if they win, believe it or not), so he just wanted to play the game.
 

Grumptronix

Fuck off, I'm not grumpy
This is easy logic! I honestly give props to MADZIN for winnnig i lost to him on losers as well. He deserved the win. NOW!! the tournament clearly states that winnings MUST be used to go to MLG and this guy isnt even coming so he shudnt have even entered on the first place as easy as that! Secondly, there needs to be a redo, why? because even tho madzin took it and not REO one match changes the outcome of the whole tournament! either someone going into losers when they coudve won on winners. Anything could change the outcome! I honestly dont care about the money i paid to entered i did it for the fun of it and the chance to play with some cool friends! This tourney was for some of us online players to have a chance at MLG and the two ppl in grand finals shudnteven have been there. REO couldnt play and Madzin is not coming so the what was the point of the tourney. There needs to be a redo and an actual online player whos willing to go to MLG shoudld take it! I would be happy if someone like blake, bwizz, krayzie or lulz i mean just anyone.

And krayzie thanks btw lol that wouldve been nice of you hehe i actually was thinking of sponsoring someone from socal if i wudve won too.

ALso, someone pitching in the $250 i think is just amazing, but he shouldnt even have to do that. the ppl responsible for what happened has to. but thats how u can tell we have immature kids in this community who dont take responsability for their actions.
Your explanation is far from logical...