So, I don't think there's a single 8-2 or 9-1 in this game so we're just gonna remove that from the conversation. However, I do want to present my definition's of what I consider a 6-4/4-6 or a 7-3/3-7.
6-4 = one character has a slight advantage over the other but the losing character can still implement their gameplan, get it started, doesn't have to sacrifice tools in the MU to win. The risk/reward for the losing character can be easily outweighed by better decision making.
7-3 = The winning character prevents the losing one from doing what they do best to an oppressive extent. Some characters can't use certain valuable tools due to lack of opportunity to do so or risk in using those tools opposed to the reward. Even if you have the better decision making, in the MU you have to make more better decisions than the other guy does.
I've also gotten a lot better at this game, as well as am playing with much better people on the whole. My list kind of shifted radically.
- Aquaman = 5-5
- Atom = 5-5
- Atrocitus = 5-5
- Bane = 6-4
- Batman = 6.4
- Black Adam = 5-5 but could be 6-4. Black Adam removes a lot of your air game.
- Black Canary = 7-3. Turtle and make her come to you, her forward movement options are super sus and risky if your footsies are good.
- Black Manta = 5-5
- Blue Beetle = 5-5
- Brainiac = 5-5 but it sure feels like a 4-6 sometimes. Anti airing is extremely hard.
- Captain Cold = 6-4
- Catwoman = 5-5 IF you have a long stage to walk her back, 4-6 if the stage is small.
- Cheetah = 7-3
- Cyborg = 6-4
- Darkseid = 7-3
- Deadshot = 5-5
- Enchantress = 6-4
- Firestorm = 5-5
- Flash = 3-7
- Gorilla Grodd = 6-4
- Green Arrow = 4-6
- Green Lantern = 4-6
- Harely Quinn = 4-6
- Hellboy = 5-5
- Joker = 6-4
- Poison Ivy = 4-6
- Raiden = 7-3
- Red Hood = 5-5
- Robin = 6-4
- Scarecrow = 5-5
- Starfire = 5-5
- Sub-Zero = 3-7
- Supergirl = 5-5
- Superman = 6-4
- Swamp Thing = 7-3
- Wonder Woman = 3-7. You can't out neutral her, you have no way to punish shield toss at max range, and she doesn't have to come to you. Lots of other small details make this MU kind of hell.