Shazam gets both! Too many variables as it really often comes down to the player and character. Characters like Batman, Joker, Aquaman, Raven, I opt for gimmicks/setups as the reward heavily outweighs the risk. Their wakeup games are one directional and easily countered albeit with meter or some but that is Shazam's problem. Characters like Bane, Doomsday sorry I mean Shoulder Charge All Day, etc. just whatever damage I can get and then I'm out of there! However should the player using said character not utilize the better aspects of the character? Setup after gimmick after setup after gimmick... You catch my drift. Granted this question varies with who people to play rather personal preference. I feel a majority of the characters in Injustice have both options available dealing decent damage with options for setups afterwards, however some characters like Scorpion, Hawkgirl, Green Lantern, Cyborg, etc. are forced to opt for the setup in most situations.