Here's the weirder version w/ all characters tested:
Works + Punish:
Batman (Slide)
Wonder Woman (Lasso Spin)
Green Lantern (Lanterns Might)
Zod (Phantom Strike, Charge)
Aquaman (Scoop) - (If trait ISN'T activated)
Lobo (Hook Charge)
MMH (Push)
Doomsday (Up-Shoulder, Shoulder Charge)
Bane (Venom Uppercut)
Harley Q. (Tantrum Stance)
Nightwing (Staff Spin)
Joker (Crowbar)
Flash (Sonic Pound)
Grundy (Cleaver, Walking Corpse)
Black Adam (Lightning Storm)
Sinestro (Arachnid Sting)
Works but unable to punish:
Lex (Corpse Charge)
Flash (Torpedo, Flying Uppercut)
Killer Frost (Slide)
Nightwing (Flying Grayson, Flip Kick)
Cyborg (Power Fist)
MMH (Martian Grab)
Bane (Double Punch)
Catwoman (Cat Claws, Max Cat Scratch)
Green Arrow (Slide)
Scorpion (Flip kick)
Doesn't Work:
Wonder Woman (Amazonian Uppercut)
Deathstroke (Sword Flip, Sword Spin)
Green Arrow (Savage Blast)
Black Adam (Lightning Storm)
Ares (Teleport)
Scorpion (Teleport)
Aquaman (If trait IS activated)
Random Outcomes:
Hawkgirl (Mace Charge)
Zatanna (Teleport)
Raven (Lift)
Unknown:
Batgirl
@
Compbros