This is probably the best pad I've personally used. The DS4 d-pad just shreds my thumb.
Amazon.com: HORI Fighting Commander for PlayStation 4 & 3 Officially Licensed by Sony - PlayStation 4: Video Games
www.amazon.com
You can use the 2 extra face buttons if you choose to do so, I don't because I'm just used to using the shoulder buttons. The triggers have also been replaced with buttons.
Edit: Forgot to mention, sometimes it sucks not having the touchpad. Can't reset in practice, and you have to grab another controller to switch to fullscreen and back when doing KOTHs and such :/