Where is Supergirl in the tier list?

Discussion in 'Supergirl' started by Mr__PancakeZ, Aug 12, 2017.


Where is SuperGirl in the Tier List?

  1. S+

    15 vote(s)
  2. S

    25 vote(s)
  3. A

    54 vote(s)
  4. B

    2 vote(s)
  5. C

    1 vote(s)
  6. D

    0 vote(s)
  7. E

    2 vote(s)
  8. F

    4 vote(s)
  1. Mr__PancakeZ

    Where and why?
  2. topper2ath

    topper2ath UPR_Nova

    Replying to because I can't wait to see what cancer comes out of this thread.
  3. methademic

    methademic UPR Methademic
    Premium Supporter

    Dis gon be gud
    x TeeJay o likes this.
  4. RM Hardway

    RM Hardway Faneto!
    Royal Contributor

    Wherever you want her to be.
    x TeeJay o likes this.
  5. topper2ath

    topper2ath UPR_Nova

    We've got that E tier too. That way, the downplayers can come in and try to not be so bad. "Hey, she's not the worst but you can block everything every time and she still doesn't get hard enough. I vote E tier."

    Edit: I was gonna edit but no, it's too funny.
    Last edited: Aug 13, 2017
  6. TheHighArab

    TheHighArab Mortal Kombats Highest Arab

    SG is obvi god tier if you pick SG your opponent will leave knowing that she is just too top tier
  7. LiangHuBBB

    LiangHuBBB Noob

    S for Salt tier
  8. It's still a little too early to be sure, especially with the recent patch, but if I had to hazard a guess... I'd peg her as somewhere between #10 and #15.

    Why? Well, she's got everything she needs to compete... but there's always a little something 'holding her back' that most of the top 10 don't have to worry about. Her zoning is good, but it's tied to trait. As of the patch she can play low risk, low reward or high risk, high reward - again, compare with top 10 characters who can play low risk, medium/high reward. Her footsie tools are decent, but nothing extraordinary.

    Matchup-wise she's a decent counter for Harley Quinn (which was true even pre-patch IMO), but struggles against characters who are good at hitting her out of the air AND have good damage - unfortunately for her, that once again is true of many top 10 candidates.

    If this ends up being completely wrong a few more months down the line so be it, but these are my thoughts for now anyway.
    gam224 and HellblazerHawkman like this.
  9. G4S Pharaoh

    G4S Pharaoh You are now in the sunken place

    even supergirl mains got a pocket supergirl now
  10. Tanno

    Tanno The Fantasy is the Reality of the Mind
    Premium Supporter

    If there was the letter "T", I would tick it.

  11. Starburrst

    I think she's still a great character especially after the patch. Her damage is below average but she's extremely safe so it evens out imo. Her mobility and zoning are also good. To me she seems like an all-around character right now. Her zoning is good, her mobility is good, her damage & combos are fine. Starfire does overshadow her though as she does everything better, & counters her. I'd put her at A tier for now.
    Last edited: Aug 12, 2017
  12. Juggs

    Juggs Lose without excuses
    Lead Moderator

    Most likely A tier. Also, I don't think anyone is S+ anymore.
  13. GLoRToR

    GLoRToR The bandwagon is the best kind of dwagon. It bans.

    A-Tier because she's fine where she is.
    x TeeJay o likes this.
  14. B. Shazzy

    B. Shazzy Retired Best Batman
    Premium Supporter

    the character is fine

    what do you mean "still a great character"? you make it sound like she got nerfed

    starfire does not overshadow her lul starfire prob loses to her even
  15. Jhonnykiller45

    Jhonnykiller45 Shirai Ryu

    She's just below the tops.
  16. Dankster Morgan

    Dankster Morgan Justice is blind, not heartless

    Probably not top ten, but like 10-15 range. She's really good.
  17. RiBBz22

    RiBBz22 TYM's Confirmed Prophet/Time-Traveler
    Premium Supporter

    SG is probably her worst MU in my theory fighting dojo
  18. Starburrst

    I think Star wins in an even matchup. It's a too early to be making these claims but for now I think that Starfire has a better zoning game & has an amazing anti-air to counter her air mobility.
  19. B. Shazzy

    B. Shazzy Retired Best Batman
    Premium Supporter

    its pretty clear starfire cant keep supergirl out effectively and struggles up close to deal with supergirls harrassment. starfire buttons dont outrange supergirl either i dont think she has literally any advantage in this matchup
  20. DeftMonk

    DeftMonk Noob

    You also think supergirl got nerfed apparently.
  21. CrimsonShadow

    CrimsonShadow Administrator and Community Engineer

    There isn't even a tier list yet (or, shouldn't be rather).

    The game was JUST patched -- now we need to take a deep breath, spend some time labbing, granding, and redoing all the matchups -- and then eventually we'll be able to say who's where.
    Pygmy_Potato, Shaka, ShArp and 2 others like this.
  22. Vengeance135

    Vengeance135 Saltiest Joker Player

    Where's the joker tier option? It should be under F-tier
    just_2swift and DeftMonk like this.
  23. Starburrst

    I've had no problems with Supergirls online. Starbolts, Stardusts, & trait are more than enough to keep Supergirl back. If supergirl tries going into the air that's worse for her as Star's B2 gives her a free combo. The reason I say this is a 5-5 match up is because if Supergirl gets up close she will give Starfire a hard time. You're making it sound like it's Starfire has a 0 chance of winning when I think it's more of a 50-50.
    Sorry phrased it like she did. I am aware she got a pretty good buff.
  24. DeftMonk

    DeftMonk Noob

    Exactly what I would say if I mained sg ;).

    In all seriousness tho there is an element of truth here.
    Vengeance135 likes this.
  25. B. Shazzy

    B. Shazzy Retired Best Batman
    Premium Supporter

    i mean we dont have o talk about it i can show you the real matchup. are you on psn?
    Last edited: Aug 12, 2017

Share This Page