General/Other Red or Blue??? Skarlet or Kitana???

[AK L0rdoftheFLY]

So through a text conversation with Mr. Mileena, I came to discover that he thinks Skarlet is better than Kitana. This is significant as I feel that Joe is one of the smartest MK players around. He is also considered amongst the top players with all three of his characters, jade, Kitana and sindel. He also has been arguing this with me since last summer and he finally changed his tune.

Now I know kit players are infamous for downplaying, and Skarlet players are thought to up-play, but now it's time to get the general consensus.

 

[MashPotatoTower]

Kitty down play in 3 .. 2 .. 1..

 

[xKhaoTik]

man who cares?!

 

[SLy]

That's kind of tough.. I think Skarlet has it better.. Kitana MU's go more smoother than skarlets though. But I think you can adapt to Kitana faster than you can adapt to Skarlet.. Skarlet just has more options than Kitana IMO

 

[THTB]

I think Skarlet is top 10. I think Kitana is no better than #11.

 

[RYX]

I don't really know what Kitana has besides being an annoying cunt, but Skarlet will just fuck you up with a full bar.

 

[CrazyBread]

You know it's topics like these that divide us more... who wants some Injustice Pie!?!

 

[Mt. Mutombo]

Wait what? lol Skarlett > Kitana?

 

[Deyrax]

Both suck.

 

[Johnny2d]

I'd say its even. There are obviously differences and arguments can be made for either case, nothing stands out to me as being over the top in either character's favor. It all depends on how you use her, in other words, its not the color of the skirt its how you get er done.

Sent from M-Class Star Freighter USCSS Nostromo

 

[Wemfs]

Jesus relax guys. It's just a simple discussion about two characters. It's not dividing anyone. If you don't give a fuck then stay the fuck outa the thread.

I think Skarlet is higher on the tier list, but only by a little.

 

[Mr. Mileena]

Omg, I'm not even that good. No need to praise me so Fly.

But yeah, I do think Skarlet is a tad better on paper. Player wise, Kitanas are doing better.

 

[Laos_boy]

I main both. Skarlet can handle every mu But Kitana can rape mu's But she also gets raped pretty bad.

Sent from my LT28at using Tapatalk 2

 

[Under_The_Mayo]

I vote Skarlett. Without a doubt.

 

[187x]

Skarlet

 

[Obs_SmSwag]

At risk of derailing the thread, who does Skarlett lose to? I feel like she has tools to overcome every MU, baring Kabal.

 

[Eddy Wang]

This

 

[Justice]

I think Skarket is a faster Sonya so that would make Skarlet at least top 5

 

[xKhaoTik]

I think Skarket is a faster Sonya so that would make Skarlet at least top 5

baraka is a more damaging Cage with more mixups. i guess he's top 10 too.......

 

[Justice]

baraka is a more damaging Cage with more mixups. i guess he's top 10 too.......

How on earth does Baraka even remotely resemble Cage? The only differences between Sonya and Skarlet are that Dash has greater range than Kartwheel, Skarlet's main projectile can be instant-aired and Skarlet's tele-drop is leagues better than Arc Kick.

 

[Johnny2d]

baraka is a more damaging Cage with more mixups. i guess he's top 10 too.......

Lol.

Sent from M-Class Star Freighter USCSS Nostromo

 

[xKhaoTik]

How on earth does Baraka even remotely resemble Cage? The only differences between Sonya and Skarlet are that Dash has greater range than Kartwheel, Skarlet's main projectile can be instant-aired and Skarlet's tele-drop is leagues better than Arc Kick.

shitty projectile, frame traps, resets, mixups, armor that travels full screen. seems similar to me.

 

[Deyrax]

baraka is a more damaging Cage with more mixups. i guess he's top 10 too.......

I agree with this man. Just beat Cage player with over 5000 wins using Baraka. Felt like a tier whore.

 

[xInfra Deadx]

Not this again...

 

[Ironsoulsmasher]

Yes, which has better TNA??