What's new

SonicFox's Top 5, Main at EVO, THEO and more

villainous monk

Terrible times breed terrible things, my lord.
Does Atrocitus have any losing Matchups? Because he dominates against a lot of the upper-mid to low tiers..
Aquaman & Black Adam give Atrocitus serious trouble. It's not a great match up for him for sure. Not downplaying but I say 6-4 clearly in their favour.

The rest are suspect and up for debates.
 

Lokheit

Noob
Sonic is a once in a lifetime player, but his character evaluation has been off a number of times to make it the first source you trust (at least the top of that list is what everyone agrees on, this is directed as those saying: see? my top5 character isn't top5 according to the fox, suck it!).

Remember when he wanted to stick to his opinion that Cryomancer was good, everybody overreacted and thought a character with literally no neutral game was OP, then during a mayor tournament WoundCowboy and Scar showed how bad Cryo is against any character with actual neutral game and Sonic stubbornly refused to switch character, lost and since then abandoned Cryo for Jason, a true grappler with actual neutral tools? I 'member. A similar case could be made about Darkseid but at least he ditched him before that tournament ended.
 
Last edited:

Eddy Wang

Skarlet scientist
You guys need to see things from your own perspective rather than just Sonic's, his tier list will change based on his own perception and this is something that can change over night, if what TYM does best these days is picking trails to follow Fox lead or try to overcome him Sonic will still dominate.

Btw, REO did the same thing in MK9

I'm more interested on Pig's Dragon, Scar anyone other than Sonic's tier list tbh
 

DeftMonk

Noob
Interesting... I kind of agree with him about redhood, lots of tools and ways to play him. When he came out a lot of tym players were saying he's garbage and I honestly just couldn't see it. He is kinda boring imo but garbage?
 

CrimsonShadow

Administrator and Community Engineer
Administrator
You guys need to see things from your own perspective rather than just Sonic's, his tier list will change based on his own perception and this is something that can change over night, if what TYM does best these days is picking trails to follow Fox lead or try to overcome him Sonic will still dominate.

Btw, REO did the same thing in MK9

I'm more interested on Pig's Dragon, Scar anyone other than Sonic's tier list tbh
The thing is, everyone is blowing up Sonic's list in this thread; but who actully disagrees with it?

I'm seeing lots of "Well it's Sonic, his lists are usually wrong", but not one convincing argument as to why any of these characters isn't in Top 5. I don't feel this particular list is controversial at all.

So if you have a logic argument as to why Black Adam, Aquaman, Atrocitus and Catwoman can't be Top 5, make it -- otherwise the fact that Sonic made this list isn't very relevant when pretty much everybody is saying the same things.
 

DeftMonk

Noob
The thing is, everyone is blowing up Sonic's list in this thread; but who actully disagrees with it?

I'm seeing lots of "Well it's Sonic, his lists are usually wrong", but not one convincing argument as to why any of these characters isn't in Top 5. I don't feel this particular list is controversial at all.

So if you have a logic argument as to why Black Adam, Aquaman, Atrocitus and Catwoman can't be Top 5, make it -- otherwise the fact that Sonic made this list isn't very relevant when pretty much everybody is saying the same things.
Ya I mean we all know badam AM and atroc are up there, people prob still are remembering the darkseid top 5 claim which now we all know to be bobo. Not a bad character just...he ain't no AM. I have played so many yolo b3/full screen ex scratch catwomen that I kinda started to sleep on her stagger game. Untill last night when I played a catwoman who was so hard to get in on it was annoying as hell.
 

Eddy Wang

Skarlet scientist
The thing is, everyone is blowing up Sonic's list in this thread; but who actully disagrees with it?

I'm seeing lots of "Well it's Sonic, his lists are usually wrong", but not one convincing argument as to why any of these characters isn't in Top 5. I don't feel this particular list is controversial at all.

So if you have a logic argument as to why Black Adam, Aquaman, Atrocitus and Catwoman can't be Top 5, make it -- otherwise the fact that Sonic made this list isn't very relevant when pretty much everybody is saying the same things.
yup very true.
 

9_Lives

Noob
I have had issue with Catwoman since day 1. IDK and idc about top 5 but many here downplay her so much man.
 

Wetdoba

All too easy...
Black Adam, batman and maybe CW
I think Bane may beat him too. I always have meter to push block trait away twice every time he calls it out so Im always fighting base Atrocitus only. With no trait against Bane it is super rough, Bane has better walk speed and armor in nuetral and destroys him on knock down
 

Red Reaper

The Hyrax Whisperer
Aquaman, Black Adam, Blue Beetle, Red Hood are all very likely 4-6. Might have some others.
Why Blue Beetle? Doesn't make sense in my head, but I don't enough.
Also, why Red Hood?
Black Adam, batman and maybe CW
Those match ups make sense.. CW might be 5/5; she tends to be 5/5 across the board. His trait still works on locking her down, but she has great footsies. So it make sense why you'd say 'maybe' on her.