What's new

Question How Close Is Smoke To Cyrax?

What do you think?


  • Total voters
    63

RM AtK!

aka - RM_AtK !
You are not automatically free to poke after blocking something against smoke because he can end anything with a sb. It makes people afraid to mash a counter poke because the risk is in smokes favor in almost every matchup. If they go for a poke after blocking a smoke neutral on block move but the smoke player ends in a smokebomb, they just ate a huge combo. If they guess right, they get a poke and a blockstring. Seems like a scary guess for smokes opponent that would make them hesitate to want to risk a poke on all of his moves that are neutral on block. Yes I get that if they read smokebomb ender after a blocked string most characters can full combo punish, but MOST characters do way less damage than smoke so the mindgame or "threat" is still in smokes favor imo
... what do u do like b2 sb standing 2 sb d3 d4 d1 sb on block all the time? also ppl can conterpoke d1 sbs etc and jump over b23 sbs on block . i fail to see your point, because all thats gonna do for u is end your pressure and quite possibly get punished for it?
 

Matix218

Get over here!
... what do u do like b2 sb standing 2 sb d3 d4 d1 sb on block all the time? also ppl can conterpoke d1 sbs etc and jump over b23 sbs on block . i fail to see your point, because all thats gonna do for u is end your pressure and quite possibly get punished for it?
No what im saying is that if you have a string blocked that is neutral (like 3d12 or b23) if the opponent wants to counterpoke so you cannot continue pressure they are always taking a risk by doing so because you have the option to throw a sb. Im not saying use sb cancels off of anything as pressure, you will obviously eat a combo if you do. Its like kung lao, just because the spin is punishable does not make the threat of him throwing it out after a string disappear. Carl used to use that threat to continue his pressure and we can all agree that was pretty successful. Plus you know you are going to have PLENTY of frame advantage from d4s that hit when using smoke so getting advantage is not a problem.
 

HGTV Soapboxfan

"Always a Pleasure"
i never said b2 can be hitconfirmed into a sb don't put words in my mouth.. if you're terrified to crouch than you have bad reads.. he pressures u with normals meaning hes neutral with you after everything he does on block. you block 1 thing you're free to poke or punish him for doing a d3 on block trying to get advantage again and continue in his OP 5050 MIXUPS <---

this is why I hate tym<-- people like you that maybe just dont understand the matchup? i've never had a problem gettin out of smokes "5050" on my alts so...
Dude coolwhip is definitely right. The point is smoke forces you to make a read where if you guess wrong you lose your health bar (you get hit by b2) and if you guess right you're neutral ( you block d4). Do you not see how the risk reward of that opens up tons of d4s?
 

THTB

Arez | Booya | Riu48 - Rest Easy, Friends
... what do u do like b2 sb standing 2 sb d3 d4 d1 sb on block all the time? also ppl can conterpoke d1 sbs etc and jump over b23 sbs on block . i fail to see your point, because all thats gonna do for u is end your pressure and quite possibly get punished for it?
You can jump over b23 smoke bomb, but what if the smoke bomb never comes? And yes, you can counter-poke d1 smoke bomb, but even with how great players have gotten at counter-poking, it's still something you have to look for and have pretty quick reactions to do so, otherwise bye-bye health.

Pressure also doesn't have to end at pushing an opponent out. Pressure through aggressive footsies can work.
 

RM AtK!

aka - RM_AtK !
No what im saying is that if you have a string blocked that is neutral (like 3d12 or b23) if the opponent wants to counterpoke so you cannot continue pressure they are always taking a risk by doing so because you have the option to throw a sb. Im not saying use sb cancels off of anything as pressure, you will obviously eat a combo if you do. Its like kung lao, just because the spin is punishable does not make the threat of him throwing it out after a string disappear. Carl used to use that threat to continue his pressure and we can all agree that was pretty successful. Plus you know you are going to have PLENTY of frame advantage from d4s that hit when using smoke so getting advantage is not a problem.
b2 3 is not neutral but ok
You can jump over b23 smoke bomb, but what if the smoke bomb never comes? And yes, you can counter-poke d1 smoke bomb, but even with how great players have gotten at counter-poking, it's still something you have to look for and have pretty quick reactions to do so, otherwise bye-bye health.

Pressure also doesn't have to end at pushing an opponent out. Pressure through aggressive footsies can work.
he better cancel it with something cuz its punishable
 

RiBBz22

TYM's Confirmed Prophet/Time-Traveler
EX ragdoll doesn't have armor...

Also, to put it better, I think Cyrax is better for sure, and I'd put Smoke at 6 or 7. Only thing I was seeing is if that gap between Cyrax and Smoke was even that great.

@Matix218 that's why I even said Smoke has pressure. Having pressure isn't purely having a lot of options to take note of that are scary...it can oftentimes be that one option that makes you scared to poke back because you have to read or die. Both of these characters do have that in common.
Yeah I corrected myself earlier. I was meaning to say that during wakeup it is a legit get off me move.
 

Matix218

Get over here!
b2 3 is not neutral but ok

he better cancel it with something cuz its punishable
Not neutral but still safe due to the pushback so the effect is the same, 214 is the same situation too. They block for an extra second in fear of sb and you get to make the next move, not them. Im not saying actually throw the sb all the time, its more threatening if you use it sparingly and keep them guessing
 

coolwhip

Noob
i never said b2 can be hitconfirmed into a sb don't put words in my mouth.. if you're terrified to crouch than you have bad reads.. he pressures u with normals meaning hes neutral with you after everything he does on block. you block 1 thing you're free to poke or punish him for doing a d3 on block trying to get advantage again and continue in his OP 5050 MIXUPS <---

this is why I hate tym<-- people like you that maybe just dont understand the matchup? i've never had a problem gettin out of smokes "5050" on my alts so...
I play Kung Lao. I never had a problem with Smoke either, but it seems like you don't understand your own character if you're comparing his D4 in vacuum, irrespective of his other tools which compliment it.

And no, you're not free to poke Smoke since he can cancel a block string into Smoke bomb if he notices his opponent getting too poke happy. You're also not always free to poke even if he doesn't cancel into Smoke bomb since some characters don't beat his D1 afterwards.

I mean if I have to explain your own character to you then you're not doing it right. I also never meant that he has 50/50's, get out of here with that shit. But rather, that his neutral game is a guessing game between D4 and B2, and yeah, it's dumb to handle for a lot of characters.
 
Last edited:

RM AtK!

aka - RM_AtK !
Not neutral but still safe due to the pushback so the effect is the same, 214 is the same situation too. They block for an extra second in fear of sb and you get to make the next move, not them. Im not saying actually throw the sb all the time, its more threatening if you use it sparingly and keep them guessing
and no with pushback means your wasting frames dashing in for another mixup = counterpoked even if they resepected ur sb cancel
 

coolwhip

Noob
lol at smoke having a 50/50 game...

you should never block low vs smoke.

A bunch of D3s and D4s > Eating a huge reset b/c you ate a B2
Jesus. Nobody meant a true 50/50. But if merely being in footsie range with Smoke means you're stuck eating D4's and terrified to block low, then that's not going to be pretty.
 

THTB

Arez | Booya | Riu48 - Rest Easy, Friends
its still punishable as in your in pressure...
They still have to dash in to get that pressure. You can smoke away out of that, too, and come back up to be within range again.
 

RM AtK!

aka - RM_AtK !
I play Kung Lao. I never had a problem with Smoke either, but it seems like you don't understand your own character if you're comparing his D4 in vacuum, irrespective of his other tools with compliment it.

And no, you're not free to poke Smoke since he can cancel a block string into Smoke bomb if he notices his opponent getting too poke happy. You'ree also not always free to poke even if he doesn't cancel into Smoke bomb since some characters don't beat his D1 afterwards.

I mean if I have to explain your own character to you then you're not doing it right. I also never meant that he has 50/50's, get out of here with that shit. But rather, that his neutral game is a guessing game between D4 and B2, and yeah, it's dumb to handle for a lot of characters.
sure dood i respect your opinion but i mean a lao player probably knows how the smoke matchups since he has to respect anything smoke does on hit<-
 

BillStickers

Do not touch me again.
@THTB needs to be blown up for this. He was in @R.E.O. 's stream last night and randomly started matchup copping, spouting nonsense that Smoke is secret top 5 and that he is just as good as, if not better than, Cyrax.

@A F0xy Grampa it's funny that you talked about fearing his command grab in pressure. That was my number one complaint with Cyrax, and THTB says (I shit you not) that "HIS COMMAND GRAB IS 14 FRAMES THAT YOU CAN EITHER READ OR REACT TO." Um, no. You need to let go of block to try to get out of Cyrax's command grab, which is a risk that you lose a lifebar for guessing wrong on.

Cyrax also has legitimate frame traps (334 is +5), ground unblockables, and one of the best d4s in the game. THTB refused to be regulated by a "troll" like me, so he made this thread out of spite for the public spanking I gave him for such insolence.
 

RiBBz22

TYM's Confirmed Prophet/Time-Traveler
@THTB needs to be blown up for this. He was in @R.E.O. 's stream last night and randomly started matchup copping, spouting nonsense that Smoke is secret top 5 and that he is just as good as, if not better than, Cyrax.

@A F0xy Grampa it's funny that you talked about fearing his command grab in pressure. That was my number one complaint with Cyrax, and THTB says (I shit you not) that "HIS COMMAND GRAB IS 14 FRAMES THAT YOU CAN EITHER READ OR REACT TO." Um, no. You need to let go of block to try to get out of Cyrax's command grab, which is a risk that you lose a lifebar for guessing wrong on.

Cyrax also has legitimate frame traps (334 is +5), ground unblockables, and one of the best d4s in the game. THTB refused to be regulated by a "troll" like me, so he made this thread out of spite for the public spanking I gave him for such insolence.
Life sucks when you are secret top 5 and you still lose to 3 of the top 4 characters :/
 

Matix218

Get over here!
and no with pushback means your wasting frames dashing in for another mixup = counterpoked even if they resepected ur sb cancel
Thats true, I do agree with that on b23 but on his other strings you are already in their face

But you are in d4 range